Two Top 5 lists today.  This first one is the Top 5 handsets I've actually gotten my paws on in some final or close to final form.  The second will be the Top 5 I haven't used, or have only groped semi-functional demos of.  Clear enough, right?  Good, let's get started:

1. Apple iPhone (AT&T) 

Problems abound with the new iPhone 3G, from lag during text entry to horrific voice and data service on AT&T in major metropolitan areas.  But iPhone is still the best all-around handset in the game, which means it's still the phone I carry every day and still rests atop my Top 5.  The closely monitored App Store extends iPhone's functionality into smartphone-meets-mini computer land, and the best-in-class touchscreen, Web browser, photo viewer, and media player make iPhone the easiest and most fun to use multimedia-rich feature phone out there.  Beware, though, Apple: the competition is creeping closer and I personally am jonesing for a QWERTY board on my phone.  Lucky for you T-Mobile and Google botched what should have been a home run in the G1 (see my Top 5 I Haven't Yet Used list).

2. BlackBerry Bold 9000 (Rogers - Canada; Coming Soon to AT&T) 

I never thought I'd actually lust after a BlackBerry but the Bold changed all of that when I tried it out at CTIA a few weeks ago.  It's everything a business phone should be with a healthy dash of style to boot.  Slim, powerful, and multimedia-rich thanks to a gorgeous new display, gussied up media player and Web browser, and integrated 3.5mm headphone jack and camera w/flash.  Could I actually leave my multitouch iPhone experience for the trackball and QWERTY board of Bold?  Ask me after it launches in the US; the answer might just be Yes.

3. HTC Touch Pro (Unlocked GSM; Coming Soon to Sprint)

If the Touch Pro had an integrated headphone jack it just might be my #1 right now (what can I say, I listen to music on my phone daily and hate Stereo Bluetooth (recharging + inferior sound quality = I'll stick with wires, thanks)).  Thanks to a potent combination of the gorgeous TouchFLO 3D interface and a slide-out QWERTY keypad, the Touch Pro serves up the best Windows Mobile experience I've seen to date.  The VGA touchscreen is small but super high-res, which caused me some data entry issues on Pro's kid brother, the Touch Diamond.  Not so here, thanks to that QWERTY board.  Pro also adds a flash to the 3.2 MP camera, which is a nice touch.  Look for Touch Pro to rule the WinMo roost on Sprint, VZW, and AT&T here in the States ... at least until Sony Ericsson finally launches the Xperia X1 (another device HTC had a part in creating).

4. Nokia E71 (Unlocked GSM)

Sexiest Nokia ever.  I know the hardcore phone phans will cry foul on this one, claiming that the N96, N95, and/or N85 should all be ranked higher than the E71.  But for me the E71 gets the nod for three reasons: Style, All-Around Functionality, and Mass Appeal.  The E71's metal body is shiny and sleek, the QWERTY board is entirely usable, and the phone packs a ton of connectivity and functionality.  While the other Nokias I mentioned may have higher-res cameras or larger displays, the E71 brings plenty to the table and provides a legitimate BlackBerry/iPhone alternative for the power user and more style and pocketability than the oversized N95/96.  If only Americans could learn to embrace Symbian ...

5. LG Lotus (Coming Soon to Sprint) 

This is my wildcard and it could come back to haunt me :-)  I was really impressed with Lotus when I tried it out at CTIA.  Why?  LG and Sprint packed a ton of functionality into a relatively small, easy to use phone.  QWERTY?  Check.  HTML Browser?  Check.  High-speed data?  Check.  Sprint Music and TV?  Check.  Camera?  Check.  Dual-displays?  Check.  The big questions here are, 1) How will it perform under daily usage in the real world, and; 2) Will people take to the somewhat strange square shape of the thing?

Honorable Mention:  LG Dare (VZW), LG Voyager (VZW), BlackBerry Curve (Multiple Carriers), Nokia N96 (Unlocked GSM), HTC Touch Diamond (Sprint), Samsung Instinct (Sprint), Nokia XpressMusic 5310 (T-Mobile)

Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Products mentioned in this Article

eBay prices for the Apple iPhone

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices