More in-depth coverage available at  TodaysiPhone - DroidDog - BBerryDog - TmoNews

Play the One-Paw Bandit!

Biggest iPhone App Store FAIL yet: Hitler’s “Mein Kampf” was approved

21
By Adriana Lee, posted Nov 9, 09 5:01 PM / 15909 views   -   add comment   -
PhoneDog on:TwitterFacebookYouTubeRss Feed
Share article:

Dear App Store: What the heck are you doing? You routinely delay or reject practical, interesting candidates, but allow passage for fart programs, cheesy joke apps, and other equally tasteless entries. You even recently denied an iPhone guide for having the audacity to include the word “iPhone” in the title. And yet, you allow Adolf Hitler’s “Mein Kampf” into the store?

To be fair, the ebook — which was in Spanish and titled “Mi Lucha” — has since been yanked. But the big question is how did it get in there to begin with? As Tech Crunch points out, Apple denied the Someecards app partially because it poked fun of Hitler, among others. (The official line is that it “contains objectionable content and content that ridicules public figures.”) Wait, so making fun of Hitler is not okay, but putting the Nazi dictator’s book on the virtual shelves is just fine? If this isn’t considered “objectionable content” then what is?

I heard the argument that maybe the confusion was due to its Spanish language translation. Sorry, I don’t buy it. Even if a huge corporation like Apple wasn’t able to hire translators or multilingual evaluators, the big giant swastika icon should’ve given it away.

Apparently it didn’t. Not only did the anti-semitic tome get approved, but — get this — it was apparently considered fine family fare: Some genius in the Approvals Dept tagged it for ages 9+.

Just for the record, I’m not into censorship. I do believe books should be widely available, and disgusting or no, this an historical work. So I don’t want to engage in a censorship debate or the controversial book’s questionable literary merits. I am, however, expressing my endless befuddlement by the App Store’s lack of logic in approving apps: Get it together, Apple. This was an epic, epic FAIL.

 

Via: TechCrunch, TheNextWeb, Edible Apple

More app reviews on PhoneDog

Abvio Runmeter: The new King of iPhone fitness apps?Abvio Runmeter: The new King of iPhone fitness apps?What’s up with you, Apple? (Part 2: App Store keeps booby apps, boots DuckPhone?) What’s up with you, Apple? (Part 2: App Store keeps booby apps, boots DuckPhone?) iPhone? Wine lover? Is NatDecants for you?iPhone? Wine lover? Is NatDecants for you?Apple finds a home for explicit apps - or not?Apple finds a home for explicit apps - or not?Video: Butterfinger ad pokes fun at iPhone appsVideo: Butterfinger ad pokes fun at iPhone appsApple yanks racy appsApple yanks racy appsVerizon Wireless and Skype announce unlimited Skype-to-Skype callsVerizon Wireless and Skype announce unlimited Skype-to-Skype callsHappy Valentine's Day, from Sweethearts candiesHappy Valentine's Day, from Sweethearts candiesMacWorld 2010: iPhone Keyboard and Apps, Apps, AppsMacWorld 2010: iPhone Keyboard and Apps, Apps, AppsChecking In: Foursquare for BlackBerry reviewedChecking In: Foursquare for BlackBerry reviewedApple allows VOIP apps to use 3GApple allows VOIP apps to use 3GThe White House launches iPhone applicationThe White House launches iPhone application

Comments & Opinions

 
Profile image icon for XProflmfao
XProflmfao @ Nov 13, 09 12:30 AM
It says 9+ age, people. Also, I bet a lot of you haven't read about Mein Kampf yet. It was written by Hitler when he was in a prison, and the book has extreme racism in it, of course most of it about Jews. Oh, lets all give 9 year olds this book so they can read about discriminating Jews! Also, the book talks about Hitler's "stages" of taking over Europe. We totally should give this book to children so they can learn the steps taking over the planet?! Stupid people, you can't get over stuff like this because the book's extremely controversial, written by the most evil dictator of the 20th century, talks about the "stages" Hitler was going to use to dominate the world, and thus shouldn't be shown to even 15 year olds, much less 9 year olds!!!
Profile image icon for icemonkey13
icemonkey13 @ Nov 12, 09 12:41 PM
This book is a part of the worlds history as much as little red ridding hood is!
Profile image icon for tchade256
tchade256 @ Nov 11, 09 12:37 PM
you guys all need to grow up. it is just a book, and might i add it is a very good book at that.
Profile image icon for betafan7
betafan7 @ Nov 10, 09 4:50 PM
New Apple ad: "Want to learn how to take over the world? There's an App for that."
Profile image icon for dfdtruck22
dfdtruck22 @ Nov 10, 09 7:14 PM
LOLZ
Profile image icon for TangerineDream529
TangerineDream529 @ Nov 11, 09 6:22 AM
Why don't they just bundle it with "Il Principe" (a book on Machiavellianism), and the "Anarchist Cookbook" and just be done with it? Want to learn how to be a bloodthirsty, war mongering, totalitarian, psychopath hellbent on ruling the world with an iron fist? We have an app for that! A+ on having balls but a solid F in tact and good taste. What in the world are they thinking?
Profile image icon for Dontex
Dontex @ Nov 10, 09 3:55 PM
Typical Apple baboonery...one word DDRRROOOIDDDD!!!....(^_^)
Profile image icon for JIMJ777
JIMJ777 @ Nov 10, 09 2:17 PM
AND THEY SAY RACISM IS DEAD..LOL.. I'M SURE!
Profile image icon for rhomaion
rhomaion @ Nov 12, 09 2:36 PM
Racism will never be dead as long as black people call themselves "african-americans" here in the states.
Profile image icon for XProflmfao
XProflmfao @ Nov 13, 09 12:32 AM
racism will never be dead as long as people view each other differently by their skin color or race. Not because black people call themselves african americans.
Profile image icon for johntkong
johntkong @ Nov 10, 09 2:12 PM
Adriana is right. Apple needs to re-evaluate their policy for apps: "Some genius in the Approvals Dept tagged it for ages 9+".

Good job Apple. Maybe someone should develop an app where a Roman soldier is stabbing Jesus in his side. With a shake of your iPhone, you too can stab the Savior.
Profile image icon for rhomaion
rhomaion @ Nov 12, 09 2:38 PM
LOL! That really shouldn't be funny but seriously I don't know what they were thinking...
Profile image icon for jamie_holland
jamie_holland @ Nov 10, 09 9:53 AM
It's an important piece of history that should be read by more, lest history repeat itself.

But damn, that icon is a hilarious oversight if it's the one that shows up on the springboard. Whoops!
Profile image icon for iSpeed09
iSpeed09 @ Nov 10, 09 12:59 AM
total fart in history...

i'm clueless as to how it managed to get in the app store. absolutely stupid.
Profile image icon for st.stark
st.stark @ Nov 9, 09 11:55 PM
haha Typical...
Profile image icon for blargables
blargables @ Nov 9, 09 10:22 PM
well the whole pic is bad, but its a book... get over it
Profile image icon for igoruausa
igoruausa @ Nov 9, 09 10:10 PM
gosh why people are so stupid, okay, hitler, so what? OMG hitler gosh.. get a life
Profile image icon for Ray111
Ray111 @ Nov 9, 09 8:10 PM
If you guys say so...

Statments saying it should have been caught due to the pic regardless of the language counterdicts the anti-cenorship statment.

Any comparison to letting this in and not letting google voice in is a "FAIL".

Add a comment

Your comments:
E-Mail me when someone replies to this comment


More breaking news

New & Coming Soon

  • Motorola CLIQ XT to T-Mobile
    Motorola CLIQ XT to T-MobileCarrier: T-Mobile Retail Price: $329.99 Phone Price: $129.99 Hot Features: Soft Touch Navigation...
  • Casio G'zOne Brigade
    Casio G'zOne BrigadeCarrier: Verizon Wireless Retail Price: $299.99 Phone Price: $249.99 Hot Features: 3G data,...
  • Motorola Backflip
    Motorola BackflipCarrier: AT&T Retail Price: $199.99 Phone Price: $99.99 Hot Features: 3G data, unique flip...
  • LG Arena
    LG ArenaCarrier: AT&T Retail Price: $279.99 Phone Price: $229.99 Hot Features: 3G data, Live Mobile TV,...
  • Samsung Caliber for MetroPCS
    Samsung Caliber for MetroPCSCarrier: MetroPCS Retail Price: $249.00 Phone Price: $159.00 Hot Features: 3.2" touchscreen...
More latest releases »




Meet the Editors

  • Noah Kravitz

    Noah Kravitz has been reporting on the consumer tech industry for over a...

  • John Walton

    John Walton is a student and writer who spends most of his free time...

  • Adriana Lee

    Adriana Lee, a journalist and admitted gadget freak, has covered everything...

  • Aaron Baker

    Aaron Baker is the Senior News Editor of PhoneDog.com and the Managing Editor...

  • Joni Blecher

    Just a few years after she got her first cell phone (the Nokia brick phone),...

  • Sydney Arnold

    Sydney is a journalist who has made it her job to know what's what in the tech...

  • Rebecca Atwood

    Rebecca Atwood has been a member of the PhoneDog.com team since the Summer of...

  • Jon Quach

    Jon is a Canadian (eh?) mobile phone enthusiast, YouTuber, and the co-founder...

  • Nate Allen

    A corporate attorney, gadget-geek, and now a contributor to Phonedog.com. ...

  • Andrew Heddle

    Originally from the UK, Andrew Heddle sold his first Mobile phone in January...

  • Ari Robbins

    Ari Robbins has a background in psychology, technology, journalism and a few...

  • Lauren Stern

    Smartphone newbie, trying to get as much work done with my newly embraced...

  • Amanda Dellario

    Amanda's love of all things tech began in early '80s arcades and blossomed into...

  • Kristi Evans

    NYC Hotel Concierge, computer geek, video gamer, movie/tv addict, avid reader,...

  • Rumor Czar

    The Rumor Czar sniffs out and tracks down the most illusive industry buzz,...

  • PhoneDog LLC

    Last but certainly not least, the PhoneDog himself chimes in every once in a...