featured
featured

Apple has recently patented “Keystroke tactility arrangement on a smooth touch surface,” and it has many thinking that Apple is currently hard at work on making the touchscreen typing experience better. If you own an iPhone, then you know that the software keyboard on that device is one of the best in the market, but there are still people out there who prefer to have a physical keyboard under their thumbs as they type. The argument about hardware versus software in the keyboard department is an on-going one, and it probably doesn’t have an end any time soon. But if these newly awarded patent ideas come into fruition, Apple may be one step closer in trying to make the arguments settle on one side, rather than another.

And while the four awarded patents may suggest more of a touchscreen input as far as computers go, they made me start thinking about the iPhone, and any other touchscreen device that has a keyboard to be typed on. I used to be a big fan of hardware keyboards, and in fact sometimes preferred them – especially when it came to devices like a BlackBerry. But, through the usage of more software keyboards, I’ve grown partial to them. I do understand why some people want the physical buttons, though: the tactile feedback provided with each keystroke is comforting, knowing that you’ve pressed a key.

Touchscreen devices have something like tactile feedback, called haptic feedback. It sends a vibration to your finger each time you select a letter on the keyboard. There are also audio cues, too: turn on keyboard typing sounds, and you’ve got yourself a “tap” every time you press a letter. But, this only goes so far. For some, if not many people, missing that feedback and physical “click” of a hard key slows them down, and they have to check which letters they are pressing.

There have been attempts at fixing the tactile “missing feature” in a touchscreen device. Namely, Research In Motion’s BlackBerry Storm and Storm 2 devices used a screen that actually “clicked” when you pressed down to activate an option, or when you were typing. This press had to be done to actually type in a letter. It may not have been as good as a physical keyboard, but it was a valiant effort nevertheless. In Apple’s case, the Cupertino-based company is looking at several different options. The most intriguing one, though, would be the usage of a frame that goes underneath the touchscreen, which would allow the user to press the key, while the touchscreen would remain flat. It does sound reminiscent of the Storm series, though.

On my touchscreen devices, I don’t use haptic feedback. Reason being, I actually think that if you’re typing fast enough, the vibrating indicator will actually cause some lag between key presses, and that’s not good at all. I do use the audio cue, though, and I find that works really well. I don’t look at the keyboard for the most part when I type, and with each audio “click” that I get from a key press helps a lot. However, I think if Apple (or any other company for that matter) could figure out a new and helpful way to incorporate an actual tactile feedback effect in a touchscreen device, it could be something that many people incorporate into their lives. (Meaning, they buy the device.)

Do you prefer a hardware keyboard, rather than a software ‘board? Or are you someone who likes the touchscreen enough not to worry about a physical keyboard? Let me know in the comments if you’d pick up a touchscreen device that offered up tactile feedback, or if it’s a feature you’re not interested in.


Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

56 Reactions to this post

"Do you want a touchscreen with tactile feedback for typing?"


Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Add
Thanks for your participation! :)

Scott Wagner
Scott Wagner As a former iPhone user, who's now stuck with this Motorola Droid piece of crap, iPhones touchscreen accuracy technology is INFINITELY more accurate and responsive than anything Moto will have for 20 years from now, from the evidence I've seen. I wish I could afford to upgrade to ANY other brand of phone on my Verizon plan. I hate this thing(my FIFTH ONE!) with such passion I'd like to break it into shards and bury them in the CEO of Motorola's backside.
Mike Trieu
Mike Trieu I wouldn't mind haptics...if they're done right. And nothing I've seen in those parent claims fits the bill. They need to have an array of rapid response piezoelectric MEMS linear actuators just under the display. With enough of these, you could gain a decent "tactile resolution". Just a thought.
Marcus Cadwell
Marcus Cadwell I like it. Helps confirm a button actually clicked
Stephane Malo
Stephane Malo Hell no, epic fail
Sharon George
Sharon George a new and improved blackberry storm 3 wud be fyn
Benjamin Padilla
Benjamin Padilla Zach Cline: You are criticizing someones grammar? The other day I saw someone criticize your grammar and you said, "You really shouldn't criticize grammar on a facebook post." By the way, haptic feedback does affect battery life. Think about it for a second, it might make sense to you.
Josh Spaugh
Josh Spaugh Physical qwerty
Jay Svoboda
Jay Svoboda Nooo!! It is sooooo annoying lol.
Jay Svoboda
Jay Svoboda Nooo!! It is sooooo annoying lol.
George Edgar Amspaugh
George Edgar Amspaugh Seriously Jonathan sorry to say this but u need to get yourself an iPod with a Nike kit and go run that fat and bad attitude off... ---Posted from my ridiculously awesome iPod touch
George Edgar Amspaugh
George Edgar Amspaugh Y do we need haptic feedback...apples screens are so responsive u don't need to worry about not hitting a key... Posted from my 4th gen awesome iPod touch
Eugene Borodin
Eugene Borodin That patent will never get approved since there are so many cases of previous art... Any decent Android VK has tactile feedback, some WM VK's have that as well. Oh wait,this is Apple and they are going to claim that they invented it....
Chase Anderson
Chase Anderson Gaaaahhhhh its that frigging TROLL @Zach again!! Spitting his stupid ass self righteous opinions again......
Scott Bitters
Scott Bitters If it's not broken don't fix it. Apple keyboard is a great now why fix it??
Zach Cline
Zach Cline Jonathan you're an idiot like most apple haters. And maybe you should work on your grammar before you run someone down that has neen more successful than you ever will be.And steve jobs just had a liver transplant dipshit. Thats why he us taking time off.
Chris Joan
Chris Joan Nope
Shawn Meadows
Shawn Meadows Its a good option to have, if you like a tactile keypad, it gives you feedback that comes from a tactile keypad bud more versatility and quickness of touch
Lynn Wheeler
Lynn Wheeler apple rocks..
Marti Ruiz
Marti Ruiz almost iphone keyboard onnandroid
Marti Ruiz
Marti Ruiz on android devices you can download many introduction methods to typing
Jonathan Rash
Jonathan Rash apple will never be good in tll steve fucking retiers
Jonathan Rash
Jonathan Rash steve jobs will never be the best ever one say and things he is but he will not give you what yall want on a device and whats the dam fucking poniit he does not make any device he spend more time suck then work why do you thing you here steve jobs is steping down again because he is the onley ceo that says he is work on a new device buy no he is in has dam all day 24/7
Ahmed Alshaiji
Ahmed Alshaiji I have that on my android phones.
Jonathan Rash
Jonathan Rash apple sucks i hate apple they all ways say that have something but it never is new all iphones are the same all ipads are the same so whats new not a dam thing
Marti Ruiz
Marti Ruiz swype is the way
Robert Salender
Robert Salender Hey Apple! Sue Nintendo for dual cameras! :O
Mason Hartley
Mason Hartley Not really it kills battery
Zach Cline
Zach Cline Haptic feedback doesn't affect battety life. And luis other phones had haptic feedback long before android.
Wyatt Likes Kittens
Wyatt Likes Kittens I have an iPhone and I really wanted one, so I Jailbroke it and got a tweak that does it for me :) But there's also a physical keyboard you can buy for it that actually looks pretty cool. Its called the TK-421 and you can get it at www.thinkgeek.com
Seaedge Val
Seaedge Val Turned off vib to save battery
Jason Kierna
Jason Kierna IPhone should have haptic feedback for typing as well as the audible "click" option
David Seifert
David Seifert No.
Dennis Tirado
Dennis Tirado No
Gabriel Ivan Amaro
Gabriel Ivan Amaro NO!!
Salomon Murillo
Salomon Murillo I would, but I won't use it a lot.
Matthew Steven Brideau
Matthew Steven Brideau Lol @ kin 2.
Carlos Mejia
Carlos Mejia How do you turn it on? I have an iPhone 4 and would love it if my phone would buzz when press a key
Jerimiah Reece
Jerimiah Reece Like the Storm? LOL No!
Anthony Stewart
Anthony Stewart tactile feedback to me is the closest thing to compliment not having a physical keyboard. Atleast with the feedback u will know that u actual touched the screen correctly.
Jamie Murphy
Jamie Murphy that would b radical. i hav a compacitive touchscreen on my kin two
Aidan Heintzman
Aidan Heintzman na it sucks and is annoying
Luis Reich
Luis Reich Another "innovation" from Apple that Android already has...
Jesse Maldonado
Jesse Maldonado YES YES YES YES!
Trey LilJohn Haywood
Trey LilJohn Haywood That would awesome I use it all the time on my phone
Nic Kolas
Nic Kolas That was the first thing I turned off
Sedrick Drake October Mack
Sedrick Drake October Mack Yea I REALLY DO
Steve Blais
Steve Blais another Patent from the patent hoards.. really Apple ?
Zach Cline
Zach Cline And swye is cool , But you can't use it all the time.
Zach Cline
Zach Cline Yes i do. If you don't like it you can turn it off people.
Moaz Bambi
Moaz Bambi What? You're saying that iPhone CAN'T have tactile feedback? LOOL it's either that or i understood this wrong.. Anyway i turn tactile feedback off on my phone.
Russell Holly
Russell Holly This follows suit with a recent article by Robert Scoble at a facility where they make these "muscles" to provide the feedback described here.
Gary DiFrancia
Gary DiFrancia no, it makes it seem like rubbish. i turn mine off.
Aaron Forde
Aaron Forde Wat is it
Marizela Moya
Marizela Moya SWYPE is where it's at...
Anonymous
Anonymous Cool,.
Johnny Tooter Shackelford
Johnny Tooter Shackelford No...I turn mine off!




Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings


See all hot devices