Being in the position I'm in, I often get asked which phone I am carrying, why I picked that particular device and even which upcoming phones pique my interests the most. Over the past year or so, I've obviously given a lot of different answers. They usually contain any given Android phone with a detailed explanation about how network or processor speeds, display size or even third-party development support make that particular phone the best at the time.

As many of you probably already know, I broke from the beaten path this past week and switched from an HTC ThunderBolt to an iPhone 4. Despite my reasons for making the jump, there are many things easily done with an Android phone that wish I could do with the iPhone. Both platforms have their own strengths and weaknesses, forcing me to carry two phones if I want the benefits of both. Truth is, I despise keeping up with two numbers and carrying multiple devices.

It doesn't require great understanding of mobile technology to know that there is no perfect phone. I learned this long ago, but only recently did I try imagining what that phone would be like if it did exist. What manufacturer would make it? What OS would it run? If I were the Dr. Frankenstein of the tech industry, what would my monster look like?


About a year ago I would have quickly chosen HTC as the manufacturer of my "perfect" phone. The Nexus One sported some of the hottest hardware to date. Recently, however, HTC has slipped into a rut. The design and materials are primarily the same as they were last year, and that's the problem. They're bland and boring with little color differentiation. (Bring on the pitchfork riot ...)

The company that has easily stuck out from the crowd, though, is Nokia. With the announcement of the N9 and leak of the Sea Ray, I have my sights locked on the Finnish-based phone makers. They consistently produce topnotch hardware and have very little trouble differentiating their devices from the crowd with popping colors and quality camera lenses. Speaking of cameras, I'll go ahead and include a Carl Zeiss lens on my perfect phone wish list.

I'm not super picky about the individual specifications like what processor it comes with or what display technology it sports. I'm a firm believer in performance over excessive specs. But for the sake of future-proofing, my super-phone would have at least a dual-core processor; but I wouldn't complain about a quad-core. There's no doubt that there are some spectacular displays out there. My vote goes to a 4-inch 720p Super AMOLED Plus display. Then, of course, the usual greedy memory hog's requests: 2GB RAM and at least 32GB built-in memory. As long as my superphone runs buttery smooth, I'll be happy.


There is no perfect mobile platform; each have their own pitfalls.

Again, a year ago, I would have quickly jumped on Android as the platform of choice. I love Android, I really do. But with all of the bugs and glitches I have run into as of late, Android and I aren't really seeing eye to eye. Sure, you could blame that on the custom software I'm constantly installing, but much of the time, this third-party software is less buggy than official software. Take MOTOBLUR and Sense UI as prime examples.

If not Android, what platform would I choose? I'll give you a hint, it isn't iOS, Windows Phone 7 or BlackBerry. The iOS platform is keeping me subdued for the time being, but it struggles in many areas. As strange as it may seem, my Frankenphone would ship with webOS. I loved my original Palm Pre and the Pre Plus, but Palm and HP's hardware is lacking. Despite the poorly stocked app catalog and ongoing infancy of the platform, webOS has some serious potential. Let's just hope with a change of pace, the platform can grow and attract more users.

The webOS platform does, however, leave one major flaw in my “perfect” phone: applications, or lack thereof. Syncing email, contacts and calendars on webOS are a breeze, but there are some apps I would have a hard time managing without like Lightbox, Instagram and Wunderlist. My minimum requirements for apps are half-decent social media clients (Twitter, Facebook, Google+, Tumblr, etc.), a RSS reader, Read It Later, image manipulation and third-party camera apps. Since all of these are available on webOS, in some form or fashion, I can see myself being truly happy on the OS.


Possibly the most important element to consider with my perfect phone is battery life. Over the past few years, cameras, processor and display technologies have come leaps and bounds. While all of these other components have vastly improved, battery technology has taken quite a blow. I do not want a processor or display that are “better on the battery.” I want a phone that actually has better battery life; something in the ballpark of two days with moderate use. For that matter, making it through a full day with heavy use would be nice.


Being so willing to jump from carrier to carrier, this is also another difficult aspect of a phone to choose, and this will naturally vary per person. I've been on Verizon since the Alltel takeover (I was an Alltel customer before). I have also been with Sprint, T-Mobile and AT&T. In my experience, Verizon's coverage has served me best. I would prefer being on GSM, but in my experience with GSM carriers, coverage in rural areas tends to drop off much more quickly than CDMA, and I spend much of my time in places more rural than I'd like to admit.

Not only is it about coverage, it is also about the 4G race and Verizon is currently leading the pack right now. I've truly missed LTE speeds since switching back to the iPhone, but hey, you can't win 'em all.

Your turn

While my perfect phone is a 4-inch, Nokia-made, webOS superphone, this is likely far from "perfect" for others. There are several things to consider when imagining your own superphone: manufacturer, platform, specs, etc. The combination and possibilites are endless. Mixing and matching manufacturer with OS, even proprietary hardware (think Retina Display), what monster device would you create, my little Frankensteins?

Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Products mentioned in this Article

eBay prices for the HTC ThunderBolt

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

31 Reactions to this post

"Do you agree with Taylor's take on the perfect superphone? "

Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Thanks for your participation! :)

Dina Locklear Ball WebOS is my current user but i might agree that android could encourage me to change...we shall see when it comes out
Lennes Shaw Oh i plan on using for college
Lennes Shaw Hey Aaron or anyone reading this im looking to get a tablet and im torn between the ipad2 and Gslate. Pls help anyone thanks
Joe Bove Oh how I miss webOS..
Ricardo Contreras Jr. Evo 3D nuff said
Lani Pasion It's all in personal preference. There is not, not will there ever be a perfect phone! If that were the case, we'd all have the same phone. Duh ;)
Angel Ortiz I love my htc sensation
Tim Gruber partially. I really like android and webos needs more apps
Kong Yang Strongly disagree.
Hansel Starley That's a terrible idea, my perfect superphone will be Iphone 4g with Nokia N8 camera. It has the apps and the sweet sweet hardware.
Leo Alexandrov People use smart phones for gaming and internet browsing. nothing productive or "smart" comes from that. only a small percentage of people use smart phones the way theyre meant to be used
Joel Gomez How can it be a superphone if there are no apps to make it super?
Steven Le No android is the best
Derrico Brown No. I stopped reading after he dissed HTC. They have came out with a lot of designs for Android and Windows. Sliders, first in America to add a ffc,bigger screens, smaller screens, multiple processors, the 1st company to pack 4g inside, diff screen qualities, new cameras, a few w/ kickstands and more.
Duldulao Ryel Ya! I'm waiting for that smartphone! When it gonna be release?
Howard Millington-Lee look out for webos a couple of tweeks here and there and and new attractive phone designs they can be a true player in the mobile industry just look how good their tablet is
Mod Bilal we don't look at the design only we need a great mobile apps :)
Jason Yu Yes, dual core,>1GB RAM, gd battery life, gd looking, made by Nokia.......These are all great choice~ But still, I prefer an Android platform rather than a webOS one.
Tham Ye Yang No! iPhone to me will forever be king in my heart :)
Dee Nazario Honestly. I rather get a blackberry.
Pavol Bán Nokia + webOS.. probably the most unlikely (in real life) combination, but I'd get this in a heartbeat.
Adrian Fernandez If you say no you've never held a Nokia smartphone or used webOS. Give me a webOS device, built by Nokia running iOS apps.
Ernest Marvin Esteban Nope. I still like android. Google just need to work on improving their UI, integration to your mails and social networking account and overall smoothness, if they improve on those 3 aspects then android will be perfect.
Keyvan Alvandi I do agree with the notion that HTC is shipping out last years material! and thats just sad!
Simon Kirshon OH WOW! This is gonna be interesting!!
Derek Simmerman If I didnt have an IPhone I would definitely have a WebOS device. Much more elegant UI than Android in my opinion. Very easy to pick up and use like IOS.
Ispongklong Dacoycoy nokia super sucks!
Dharry Mejico Fraga webOS on nokia!!!! a dream come true!!!

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices