close
Find us on Google+

Should phones stop working while we're behind the wheel?

There is no question that distracted driving is a serious problem, or that cell phones are a major cause for distractions in drivers. Thanks to those tiny little devices that keep us connected at all times, we like to live in the moment, here and now. Everything must be attended to right away. Nothing can wait.

Of course, this isn't how it should be – not behind the wheel, at least. A text message can and should usually wait. And if it can't, pulling over to respond or placing a voice call – hands-free if necessary or possible – should be high on the list of priorities.

To date, only a couple measures have been put in place to help avert in-car distractions. One, for instance, has been a ban on texting while driving, which has been adopted by the majority of the states. However, such laws have done little to prevent further accidents or stop people from texting while driving. There has been a lack of enforcement, and some studies show that the issue has only gotten worse due to drivers holding their phones lower to hide their texting from any nearby law enforcement; thereby, lowering their head and eyes, looking further from the road and effectively slowing reaction time.

Without the slightest doubt, something needs to be done. Careless drivers who simply cannot wait to respond to a text message are putting thousands of lives in danger every day.  And it's beyond just text messages. Twitter, Facebook, music, email, Web browsing and other functions of smartphones are all causes for distractions, too.

So what should be done?

Well, people should simply learn to put their phones down while they're behind the wheel. But without incentive or (what they deem) a good reason, few people will put notifications on the back burner until the car is stopped. Their life – that text – is clearly more important than the safety and well being of others.

A report coming from Reuters yesterday evening claims that the Obama administration "wants limits on vehicle features that allow drivers to text and make cellphone calls while the car is moving." Yesterday, Transportation Secretary Ray LaHood proposed some steps to automakers that would limit on navigation systems, hands-free calling and other parts of entertainment systems within cars. John Crawley of Reuters explains:

"The Transportation Department guidelines introduced on Thursday recommend that automakers adopt technology to disable distracting electronic systems that are accessible to the driver -- but not passengers -- when a car is moving.

This would cover text messaging, Internet browsing, and access to social media."

Generally, I'm all for anything that will help save lives and, ultimately, put an end to texting (or any cell phone use while driving, for that matter) while driving. But this proposition clearly isn't the way. It could create more problems than it solves.

For starters, while the driver may need to have their text messaging or Interned browsing blocked, a passenger doesn't. How could a system possibly block these services for the driver yet not block the use of a passenger's device? How would it block certain functions of a phone while leaving others, like built-in navigation, unhindered? And completely disabling a driver's device while the car is on isn't the answer either. This would prevent them from dialing emergency numbers in the case of, well ... an emergency.

What's worse is the simple fact that no matter what length the government or law enforcement agents go to, people will go to greater lengths just to keep doing what they want. Create a system that disables certain functions of the phone and, somewhere, some hacker will find a way around it.

Regardless, a little more force – better enforcement of laws and maybe even more serious consequences – is all that can realistically be done. The NTSB (National Transportation Safety Board) proposed that all cell phone use behind the wheel should be banned. And while I'm not 100 percent sure I can agree with that, as hands-free is hardly worse than chatting with a person in the passenger seat, laws are the right way to go – at least for now.

There is no single way to remove all distractions from drivers. But with more advanced built-in features within cars, we can only hope drivers become less and less distracted and this growing issue subsides. One thing is for sure: I'm not holding my breath, and I won't be contributing.

What say you, ladies and gents? Are distracted drivers getting worse. Is LaHood's proposal the best approach? Or should all cell phone use behind the wheel be banned, period?

About the author

Taylor Martin
Taylor Martin is a Contributing Editor for PhoneDog and has over six years of experience with BlackBerry and two or more years of hands-on experience with mobile platforms like Android, webOS, and iOS. When he isn't writing into the wee hours of the morning, Taylor is hacking, tweaking, and modding one of his phones or tablets to do his laundry and cook his breakfast. Away from cell phones and other gadgets, Taylor spends his time with friends... - full profile
Become a PhoneDog Fan on Facebook and don't forget to "Spin to Win!" today! Know something we don't? E-mail us or post it on our Facebook page

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

1 HTC One X

HTC One X

341 Votes Change+-0
2 Nokia Lumia 900

Nokia Lumia 900

257 Votes Change+-0
3 Samsung Galaxy Note

Samsung Galaxy Note

148 Votes Change+-0
4 Apple iPhone 4S

Apple iPhone 4S

99 Votes Change+-0
5 HTC One S

HTC One S

85 Votes Change+-0
1 HTC One X

HTC One X

Chosen by
43 points +1
All experts who rated this Smartphone
from ranked this as the # - see why
close
Expert ranking history for this smartphone
6 weeks on the charts
Ranked # : week of
close
2 Apple iPhone 4S

Apple iPhone 4S

Chosen by
42 points -1
All experts who rated this Smartphone
from ranked this as the # - see why
close
Expert ranking history for this smartphone
19 weeks on the charts
Ranked # : week of
close
3 HTC One S

HTC One S

Chosen by
21 points +-0
All experts who rated this Smartphone
from ranked this as the # - see why
close
Expert ranking history for this smartphone
6 weeks on the charts
Ranked # : week of
close
4 Nokia Lumia 900

Nokia Lumia 900

Chosen by
16 points +-0
All experts who rated this Smartphone
from ranked this as the # - see why
close
Expert ranking history for this smartphone
6 weeks on the charts
Ranked # : week of
close
5 Samsung Galaxy Note

Samsung Galaxy Note

Chosen by
11 points +1
All experts who rated this Smartphone
from ranked this as the # - see why
close
Expert ranking history for this smartphone
12 weeks on the charts
Ranked # : week of
close
Vote this week See the full list

 

96 Reactions to this post  
"How do you feel about restrictions on your phone while driving?"
Add Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
  • Max HaghighiAgain, majority getting punished for the actions of a few morons!Feb 20th
  • Clifton G. HarpNo. That's why we have Siri on the iPhone. That way you can do stuff you need to do like sending texts, but safely behind the wheel! ;-)Feb 18th
  • Anthony V CannataYes they shouldFeb 18th
  • José J. LandrauOn one occasion a guy got almost hit by a car because the stupid driver was on the phone and on another occasion i had to literally yank a friend by his arm back to the sidewalk because another stupid driver was on the phone.Feb 18th
  • Josh HamiltonOn my way to work this morning some numb nut was fiddling with his phone, hopped a curb and bounced off a telephone pole back into on coming traffic, thankfully he didn't hit any one else.Feb 17th
Latest videos

Featured stories

close
close
close