I had a lot of fun testing the differences between popular subscription music services Rdio and Spotify. While both options have their own pitfalls, there’s no doubt that each service will offer up just enough to attract plenty of customers. Rdio is popular, and so is Spotify. But, while there are other options out there, some that don’t have as many features and don’t cost the same every month, I find that Rdio and Spotify offer up the most for the monthly cost. But, I’m still left wanting more.

And I’m left wanting more for one simple reason: Zune. Not too long ago I made it perfectly clear that I don’t believe getting rid of the Zune Software from the Windows Phone ecosystem is a good idea, and it goes a bit deeper than what I outlined in tat previous article. Simply put, I think the Zune Software, and the monthly music subscription service that it offers, are fantastic.

And I miss it.

The way I left the Zune Software and Zune Pass wasn’t pretty, either. We separated on ugly, evil terms. I’m a firm believer that when you buy music, no matter how you buy music, that it should be yours. You should, considering that it’s a digital download, be able to download that purchased music as often as you want, no questions asked. Because you bought it. It’s yours.

Apparently Microsoft’s terms don’t necessarily see it that way. You see, I have been using Zune Pass for as long as it’s been around. I loved it right from the start because I was paying $14.99 per month for unlimited music, and a bonus. The bonus was 10 song credits that I could use to “purchase” music at the end of every month. 10 credits, plus unlimited music a month, for a pretty cheap price tag. I was hooked, and considering how much music I download every month, it was saving me a boat-load.

And then it all came crashing to a halt when, a few months ago, I was trying to download my previously “purchased” music and it said I couldn’t. When I tried to find out why, it said that I had reached my limit of downloads for this particular song, and that I could either access it through the Zune Pass (streaming), or purchase it again.

Purchase it again? Why? I already purchased it. I already did that. Which means I should already own it. Right?

When I reached out to customer service, they told me that there wasn’t anything that they could do. I had reached my limit, end of story. But hey, I could stream it or purchase it again, and that’s perfectly okay, right? No, no it isn’t.

That’s why Zune Pass and I separated, and while I hate the fact that even the songs I’ve purchased, whether it was through the free credits or through my own money (or Microsoft Points), I still miss the service. Because, as often as I use Rdio (over Spotify), Zune is just better in my opinion. When I listen to music I tend to just open my song list and hit shuffle. That will last me all day. But, the way that Rdio is set up, allowing for only 100 songs to be played during one play through, that just leads to a lot of repeated songs.

It’s so bad that I actually counted how many times I heard one particular song, one song out of over 6GB worth of music, played during five play throughs. I heard it six times. That’s just with shuffle on, and not repeat. It gets worse when you multiply that by five or six songs, at least. My shuffle is basically a repeat of something I’ve heard previously, despite the fact that there’s still songs in my playlist or library that I haven’t heard.

I never had a problem with this using Zune Pass. In fact, I’d venture to say that hitting shuffle with a Zune is a better experience than it is when listening to music on either an iPhone or an Android-powered device, which is pretty top-notch on its own. I didn’t even think this could be a problem. Then I realized that it’s just the way that Rdio is set up. The fact that it has to pick 100 songs before it can even start playing, means that you’re more than likely going to get repeated tracks. It’s unfortunate, but that’s just the way it’s set up.

It’s better than picking 25 songs before playing, though, which is how it used to be with Rdio.

That’s why I want the Zune Pass for other platforms like iOS and Android. I want to have Zune Software available for Mac, and I want to be able to access Zune Pass from my iPhone whenever I want. It’d just be an app, but I could collect my music the same way, access the vast Zune library, and (hopefully) wouldn’t have to suffer through these shuffle issues.

This is only made worse by the fact that several of my colleagues are now using Windows Phone handsets, Zune Pass, and loving the unlimited music option. I’m jealous, because while I have a subscription music service, I feel like I’m paying to listen to the same music over and over again while I’m using it on my phone.

If you use Rdio, do you run into this problem? If you do, how do you get around it? And, more to the point, would you want Zune Pass available for iOS or another platform? Let me know what you think.


Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

43 Reactions to this post

"What's your favorite music platform?"

Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Thanks for your participation! :)

Jason Westrupp
Jason Westrupp I say yes and so does a lot of iPhone users I know who which iTunes was half as good interface wise as zune is...
Eric Quach
Eric Quach Go old school. lol the guy in my class next to me literally just pulled out an old Sony CD player.
Anthony Andrade
Anthony Andrade Ios
Oscar Alejandro Trujillo
Oscar Alejandro Trujillo Cassette tapes all the way
Corey Stock
Corey Stock I have no idea where people are getting this notion that IOS has a better music player than Google. Try and sync an iPhone with music on it to a different itunes library. Tell me how that works out.
Devin Martinez
Devin Martinez It's funny how these gaydroids scream google lol yeah right better then the iOS music & media Eco-system ? I think not b¡tches !
Amer Ahmed
Amer Ahmed Google gay? How old is this guy?
Marti Ruiz
Marti Ruiz Google music.
Aaron Delgado
Aaron Delgado Yes its good for them like spotify and all the other
Jordan Brown
Jordan Brown I like Spotify a lot, I use it on iOS.
Adrian Anguiano
Adrian Anguiano iOS by far has the best music ecosystem iTunes is superior to any other google music service and is also reliable. Sorry android and google but y'all are not there just yet as far as the music ecosystem goes
Nick Chimento
Nick Chimento No. That's the best thing Windows Offers
Lorenzo Maldonado
Lorenzo Maldonado cm9 music and sense magic app
William Smith
William Smith Microsoft is losing focus if anything they should take a page from Google and try to enter grate anything into everything!
Francisco Aceves
Francisco Aceves It would be great.. if they just made it worldwide.... Microsoft might not know but the world is quite larger than the USA
Zach Cline
Zach Cline Google gay! lol.have to love the google/ android fanboys.
Jesse Snider
Jesse Snider Google Play! Android has this music thing down pat. No need to mess with other programs, apps, the Google Gods know what they're doing.
Derek Lombardi
Derek Lombardi Google Music.. upload.. and stream or pin to an Android device.. or stream on any web enabled device you're signed in on.. Brilliant!
Jabin George
Jabin George why
Jose Valladares
Jose Valladares Spotify :)
Jonathan Swanagan
Jonathan Swanagan yes
Chayse Collier
Chayse Collier Yeah they should. I used to love Zune Pass on my Xbox, but I cancelled it when I couldn't use it on my Droid 2 and Rezound. If there's a similar service available on Android let me know or something so I can stream music at work
Jew-Duh McAlister
Jew-Duh McAlister I'm very satisfied with my zune player on wp. I'm a hard copy collector and I appreciate it when my music is displayed well into my device. I have nothing less than pride for my zune player. It keeps me entertained, it's fluid and has a better ui experience than any other experience I've had. Even if you're a pure apple/android user, you're a slave if you give it a bad rating. You can't be too reliant on just one perspective. I however am super jealous of the free 20,000 song on cloud. As far as zune on any other platform? I doubt it. The only likelihood I see is it may end up on symbian devices, but probably not.
Su Zahir
Su Zahir Nope it had it's opportunity to be what Google Music is has passed
Ken Rowe
Ken Rowe I'm with Tim Smith.
Steve Bachman
Steve Bachman Google music works well and does what it's supposed to do
Joseph Olvera
Joseph Olvera I think yes.
Jose Cervantes
Jose Cervantes Yes because I can't play all my music with Google :/
Scott Beaudoin
Scott Beaudoin yes
Mohd Reza
Mohd Reza Zune is not available in Doha
Tim Smith
Tim Smith No because that's going away but rumor is Woodstock the new service will be multi-platform. Which I think is a good idea.
Yuvi Love
Yuvi Love cassette tapes on my sony walkman
Zach Cline
Zach Cline Google music is a fail so I would say yes.
Sonny Cavazos
Sonny Cavazos I am moving from ZUNE to Google Music as well..
Fark Mukerberg
Fark Mukerberg i cant talk about this. i am NOT american so microsoft is ignoring me. you know the zune is only avaible in the USA. i dont dislike microsoft but if they ignore the European market they can f'ck off quite frankly
Pascal Hertinge
Pascal Hertinge Spotify
Jose Be Julme
Jose Be Julme No. Android doesn't need you. Google Play is fine.
Sujit Tiyar
Sujit Tiyar htc beats audio
TB Ogungbadero
TB Ogungbadero Google music serves me well.
David Sabillon
David Sabillon Google music. Really. Just upload music and listen with what ever android device you have. Awesomeness!
Richard KaOs Doyle
Richard KaOs Doyle nope Microsoft can keep Zune Android has plenty of music services as is
Chan Yi Tian Thomas
Chan Yi Tian Thomas Yes.
Jake Denning
Jake Denning lol no

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices