Last week, Microsoft gave us a sneak peek of what to expect when Windows Phone 8 is released this fall. They highlighted eight (get it?…Windows Phone *8*) new features including a new Start screen with more tile sizes and options, support for multi-core processors, HD displays, and SD cards, as well as a new hub called Wallet. All in all, it's a big update so, naturally, everyone wants it. The problem is that not everyone will get it. Yes, Microsoft confirmed our worst fears by adamantly stating that current Windows Phone devices will not get the Windows Phone 8 update.

To put it simply, this bites, and it brings to mind the problems that other OSes have had with software updates. Android's fragmentation problem is, well, you know the story. A new update comes out and you'll be fortunate if your phone actually receives it, but not after waiting for six months. Apple just announced the latest version of its OS, iOS 6, and held back some of its best features from devices that are merely one generation old. Android gets flack for fragmentation. iOS is getting more heat for its new-found fragmentation. Are Windows Phone fans' worst fears coming true? Is Microsoft unfairly and unnecessarily with-holding an update?

The truth is that yes, this will cause a fragmenting of Windows Phone devices. However, it's not as severe as the fragmenting we see in Android and it's certainly not as unreasonable as the fragmenting that Apple has started. Microsoft actually has good reason for not updating current Windows Phone devices. It goes like this:

First, think of some of the biggest new features in Windows Phone 8: support for multi-core processors, HD displays, and NFC. Those are obviously not features you simply send out an update for. It makes sense, right? Unless Microsoft is going to magically force a dual-core processor into your Titan II, this update wouldn't help you. Even a software update for SD card support (which Windows Phone 8 includes) wouldn't help because most manufacturers ditched the slot completely after the problems it caused. This also explains why current Windows Phone devices probably won't get the Wallet hub - without NFC, it's only half as useful (though, for the record, I still want it, even without NFC).

However, the main reason why current Windows Phone devices won't get Windows Phone 8 lies below the surface. Unlike Windows Phone 7, Windows Phone 8 actually shares the same core technologies as Windows 8 - the same kernel, drivers, file system, etc. Therefore, this isn't merely an update to Windows Phone, it's really a redesigning of what makes the OS, down to its very core. The native code is just different - it's now shared with Windows 8. In a sense, Windows Phone 8 is as much of an overhaul as Windows Phone 7 was. Remember, Microsoft explained that Windows Mobile devices wouldn't be updated to Windows Phone 7 because it was virtually a completely new operating system. The update from Windows Phone 7 to Windows Phone 8 isn't quite as dramatic, but the principle still applies. Even gaming development will see a change with DirectX (think 'Xbox-type games') now being the basis for native game development.

Now, there are some benefits to this. In fact, the reason that there is now support for multi-core processors, microSD cards, and more is actually the switch to the NT kernel shared with Windows 8. Also, now that DirectX is being used for native game development, we should expect to see "some freaking killer games this year", according to Joe Belfiore, manager of the Windows Phone Program at Microsoft. There are other improvements, too, like more security, better performance, and a more seamless experience for developers.

So now you know why your Windows Phone device won't be getting this update. The good news is that this shouldn't happen again. Switching to the shared kernel with Windows 8 is a one-time thing. Further updates should be available to everyone, at least for up to 18 months after you buy your phone, according to Microsoft. (For the record, I've heard that before). The transition is painful now, but it was necessary. Microsoft is even taking care of its loyal customers by giving everyone a Windows Phone 7.8 update that includes the new Start screen which, when you think about it, outside of the HD displays and multi-core processors (which we've already established is an impossible feature to provide for legacy devices), that's the biggest thing to look forward to anyway.

Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

13 Reactions to this post

"Is Microsoft taking a page from the Android playbook with the Windows Phone 7.8/8 ordeal?"

Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Thanks for your participation! :)

Eric Magana
Eric Magana WM7 FTW
Kedrian Hardy
Kedrian Hardy lol
Bryan Prime
Bryan Prime Wow people are ignorant. Lets spell it out really slow for those of you who need ten minutes to process stuff... ready? Microsoft (the people that build the os), has already said that Windows Phone 8 will have NFC (near field communication which is the ability to wave your phone and buy stuff). So if windows 8 will have it and current windows phone dont support it.... guess what? You cant update to it without leaving out core features that makes windows phone 8 different. How about you tmobile g1 users, are you running ics?... no! Oh! Google must be evil!
Anthony Andrade
Anthony Andrade Everything the hardware can handle, they are giving to older phones. But some things like NFC and dual cores, the phones do not even have anyway.
Jeff Jones
Jeff Jones I hate all this BS with phone OS updates. You don't have to buy a new computer every time a new version of Windows, Mac OS, Linux, etc. come out, so why should you have to buy a new phone for nearly every new version of Android/iOS/WP? It's a ripoff and a money grab and it pisses me off. Fine you don't want to give it to us for free, charge like $20 or so. I think that could work.
Juan Carlos Munoz
Juan Carlos Munoz Well put dre. The average person is a fucking idiot. These companies know this. That's why at&t and verizon are getting away with murder!
Dre Ill
Dre Ill Android playbook huh? With the exception of a few, this has always been common practice. From a business standpoint, updating previous models for free doesn't yield a profit. Problem is, we accept it.
Bernie Fen
Bernie Fen WP blows!.. i've had a chance to experience Lumia 900 hands on and was not even impressed. Sorry - truth hurts.
Tabib Rehman
Tabib Rehman ios wont give the iphone 4 turn by turn navigation which is pathetic since android have been using it for years
Jammari Hall
Jammari Hall No
Wasis Waskito
Wasis Waskito How to spell "conspiracy"?
Lovish Gupta
Lovish Gupta Sort of..
Tony Abiama
Tony Abiama Umm no... doesn't iOS do the same thing with their updates with older Iphone's? Just BAU

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices