It’s a question we pretty much ask ourselves anytime we see a new device being released: what makes this device stand out from any of the others out on the market today? What makes this device better than the others? What can this device give me that others can’t? While a multitude of factors play in to why a device is “great” in our eyes, it’s ultimately up to the individual’s taste and preferences on what features work best for them in a smartphone. While devices will continue to wow us with new technology, I feel that there are some basic stomping grounds that need to be featured before delving into the specifics.

Generally, to produce a device that the masses will label as being the best of the best, companies have to make sure of they have a couple of key things: innovation and great timing for starters. For the longest time Apple was the innovator; it was their device that, while it may not have been the very first smartphone in the market, was the one that people flocked to. Not only was the first iPhone considered "innovative" by many, but it was innovative at a time when people accepted that kind of innovation. It takes two elements for innovation to work: the idea, and pitching the idea at the right time. Both iOS and Android have seen success with this formula; however, it may be too late for BlackBerry 10 to succeed using the same formula because they might have waited a little too long to revamp their product. Time is extremely essential in the mobile phone world, because even waiting an extra month can risk a company presenting outdated software.

Innovation and time are very important in a device, but a device also needs accessibility; a flow, a certain feng shui that people can adjust to within a short period of time. Carriers generally give customers about two weeks to make a decision on whether they want to keep a device or not. If a customer can’t figure out what’s going on with their device within two weeks, most people don’t have a problem paying a restocking fee to exchange the device for something that works; after all, they’ll be keeping this device for about two years, give or take a little bit. The higher the return rate, the worse the reviews will be. Everybody knows that bad news gets talked about more than good news, and people are quick to report on the bad if it’s actually taken time out of their schedule to address a problem. Even if a platform is a little more difficult to understand at first than others (Android vs. iOS for example) Android still has a pretty good flow throughout the device – most of them even take you through a tutorial when you first get the device so you understand how the commands work. Even if you want to make a device with a more complicated platform you’ll still need to have the basic functions of the device be easily accessible, otherwise you can expect it to flop.

Last but not least, a device has to have a comfortable and attractive design. While not everybody will agree that an attractive design is essential, I think everyone can agree that nobody wants to carry around a device that is uncomfortable to hold. If phones keep heading in the direction they’re going in and continuously growing larger (I read a rumor today that said that a Sony Xperia device might be 6.44 inches – that’s literally about a half an inch smaller than a tablet, who are we kidding?!) we can expect to see humans with gigantic hands in about 20-30 years’ time. As odd as the iPhone 5 might look compared to other devices with large screens, Apple might have had the right idea by making the device taller. Making a phone too wide just isn’t comfortable to hold for long periods of time. With a taller device, you still have the added visibility factor without having to worry about cramping your hand after a lengthy phone conversation. As for the attractiveness, it might not be essential but as humans we have a tendency to like to shift our attention to things that we find pretty. Point and case, while I was working at Sprint we got a new basic phone on the line – a clunker of a phone called the Kyocera DuraPlus. It had a rugged design that was meant for those who worked in the elements, but looked like it was sent there straight from the 90’s. Next to the DuraPlus was two other rugged phones (not as rugged, but rugged enough) that featured more attractive designs. These were the go-to phones for anybody who specified they needed something durable. Although the DuraPlus was probably the most durable phone we had, nobody wanted it because it was an eyesore. Completely functional and got the job done, but ugly as homemade sin.

While I feel these are some of the basics of what make a device start off on the right path, where the company takes the phone next is where the real challenge begins. There are a lot of factors on what makes a device become the best of the best, and the answers will change no matter who you ask. For one person it might be a stellar camera; for another it might be how much storage a device can hold. So this is where I ask you, reader: What factors determine a great device to you? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below!


Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

54 Reactions to this post

"What factors determine a great device to you?"

Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Thanks for your participation! :)

Arpit Gohil its processor and screen
Anonymous uniqity to the device build quality
Anonymous Having what the consumers want (Battery and Micro SD card slot) Giving the most options possible. How unique it is qualities that make it different from others personalization keys and design and quality feel
Siva Rajan uniques ness and easy user interface. people say appearence are deceptive but mostly its the appearence what people are attracted!
Jeff Seaver Now Carry 4 different phone my choices are 1) HTC Butterfly 2) Samsung Galaxy S3 3) iPhone 5 4) Galaxy Note 2 too heavy Note 2 HTC Best Screen and Samsung Galaxy S3 love the customization by Samsung
Jeff Seaver The screen. Response from screen. Speed. If is Android quick update. Light and slim.
Anthony Davis HD screen. Screen atleast 4.5" long. Good grip to it so it wont fall out of the Hands too easy. 4G lte speeds. At least a 1.5GHZ dual core CPU' s. And looking battery life. 9/13 hrs on ave.
Walter Van Lille High build quality, awesome screen, good camera. Quality material and a little something in the design that makes it look different. These are all things that I've been seeing in Sony's phones recently.
Marcus Monet The factor is a qwerty keyboard and the Blackberry OS. I hate Android and iOS!
Ezraella Brody Ease of use, easy to read sceen, decent screen size, great camera. I find this & more in my samsung SIII
Jesus Salvador Delgado Martinez doesnt feel like a cheap plastic phone (samsung)
Joel Diaz I just hi fived myself
Joel Diaz It's gotta pack android.
Mark Belkowski what he said
Jose Angel Santiago Note 2...enuff said!!!
Julian Scott Battery life 4 sure, then app performance like"facebook and instragram ect...
Abram Wenevermet Dennis Battery life is #1 reliability is #2
Gregory Mckenzie It not being a Inferior-Phone, my bad I meant I-Phone.
Grant Young Motorola
Gordon Christie the words samsung galaxy note 2
Ghâssânò Alredmân display size, dual sim and audio enhancement
David Juarez Yes. Specs mean nothing over the overall user experience. I own the sgs3 and the user experience is awesome.
Kristoff Lewandowski Idiots will says specs. Me, durability.
BG Michael LG Optimus G Pro. BATTERY LIFE!
Marlon Milligan The epic screen like on the Note 2 or the One series & DNA
Randy B Hoopes Stability
Dave Morgan Any device that doesn't have a piece of fruit on it is great in comparison.
Freddie Devone Innovation ;)
Shahnwaz Don Oh yeah! Ofcourse i wanna to tell those facts which are some KEY FEATURES of smartphones thesedays! Processor's power! Ram amount! Display type & size! Connectivity! Storage Capacity! And last but not least Manufacturer Company!
Michael Scott H everything my Note 2 has that others don't have
Marcus Samual Winchester Smoothness, enterprise capabilities, connection features, os upgradeability and expandable memory. Thats why the Galaxy S3 wins for me, and consequently so would the Note 2
Jason Paul Traylor Has to be the note Samsung Galaxy Note 2!!! although i wish it has the new Exynos 5 Octa in it like the supposed Note 3 with the 6.3 in display
Jourdan Fletcher Processor, HTC built, screen quality, android (rooting is a must )
Marti Ruiz battery life, features. vivid screen (superamoled)
Lawrence Lepes The processor, ram, internal memory, expandable memory, flash player, size of the screen, and the Super AMOLED Screen!
Brandon Moran No Apple Logos? ; ) Lol.. Nah seriously, Decent battery (meaning moderate usage and last thru the workday at least..) Smooth frames, Good processing speed, and Good Pic/Video taking. Durable Hardware, and Stable software too.. Customization and lack of restrictions is a plus as well.. I guess.. Android 4.2 or higher then.. ; )
Qi Ren camera, speed and stability.
Christopher Manic Johnson Good processor, a nice shooter, and decent battery life. This part is bias, but it has to have Android on it, just because of the different customizations you can achieve, and most likely those customizations can improve performance.
Dee Nazario In order: 1. Performance 2. Battery Life 3. Screen Size.
Tony Abiama Screen quality and size, battery life and speed.
Heriberto Eddie Mendoza Battery life and being durable and great photo capabilities.
Antonio Horn Screen size, battery life.
Olavi Pyhtilä Harmattan UI.
Jose Calderon Nothing superficial like screen size, that's for sure.
Dustin T. Robles Samsung galaxy s III and a mix of the App Store and google play
Eric Hook Nexus 4 ... any nexus device or anyone that has Samsung on it and NOT apple
Angel Jewels Exactly Mark Saint... More often than not, when you get a new mobile phone it can't even make a call... But will take beautiful pictures... Smh Reliability is the #1
Dietrich Brown Battery life #1
Mark Saint doing the job it was purchase far

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices