featured
featured
PhoneDog Media Exclusive
Download iM5, now available in the App Store and Google Play. iM5 is a PhoneDog Media backed Social Platform to inspire real-life action through the crowdsourcing of ideas. See the video

Fragmentation!

Okay, just had to get that out of the way. This isn’t an article about how terrible fragmentation is. In fact, I’m going to embrace it from here on out. Why? Because there’s just no getting away from it. And, simply put, it shouldn’t matter. You don’t buy your phone for what it will do, but what it does now. For all those cool features that the manufacturer was so happy to show off during its unveiling. You buy the phone you heard about in the news. Software updates that are focused primarily on features rather than security are bonuses.

Last year I wrote about why it probably shouldn’t matter if you’re running an Android version that’s one behind the “latest.” And, let’s face it, if you’re someone who’s excited about picking up the HTC One, then you’re also excited about being one version behind the latest. But there’s nothing wrong with that at all. It would be a major issue if the One was launching with Android 4.0 Ice Cream Sandwich, and specifically without Google Now, but it isn’t, so you’re fine. Does it matter that Samsung is launching their Galaxy S 4 with Android 4.2 Jelly Bean? Nope.

More recently, Taylor Martin wrote a piece asking you if you care if you have the newest piece of software on your phone. I know a lot of people that this is, in fact, a big deal. It is such a big deal, in fact, that they are now actively avoiding some devices on some carriers, and going with a phone that they don’t particularly like all that much, just so they don’t have to worry about software updates. On the other hand, I know plenty of people that just don’t care. Their phone works, so why should they? If a notification comes to their device that they should upgrade their software, that new and exciting features await them, that’s great. Update, and move along.

Right now, right this very moment, there are a lot of people talking about Facebook and what the company plans on unveiling in just a few days. April 4, to be exact. That’s the day that the social network giant has pegged to unveil their “new home on Android.” So, obviously we’re talking about software and not hardware, right? There’s a chance. But, there are plenty of rumors of that Facebook phone, too. It’s most recent phone is codenamed the “Myst,” and it has some phenomenally mediocre features. But hey, it’s new and it’s all Facebook-y. So people will probably want it.

I’m not going to talk about whether or not we really need a Facebook phone. I’m going to leave that up to our own Anna Scantlin.

Instead, I want to talk about Android. I want to talk about why your version doesn’t matter. I want to talk about why, more than ever, Google’s Android team is working harder than ever to just get shoved into the shadows and forgotten about, until that “next big version.”

Let’s face it, we all want features. We want Android to pack in so much that we can show it off to friends, family and complete strangers. But, companies like Samsung, HTC, and Amazon want you to buy their things for their proprietary software. Not because of Android. Look at Samsung and Amazon. Sure, Android is in there somewhere, but TouchWiz and Amazon’s custom software are so prevalent and in-your-face that you’d be remiss if you had no idea.

And, here’s the rub: it doesn’t matter if you do or don’t. Amazon’s Kindle Fire tablets are ridiculously popular. And, let’s be frank, Samsung’s smartphones are even more popular. The fact that the Galaxy S 4 is launching with Android 4.2 and not Android 4.1 will not make or break sales. It won’t have an impact on sales at all. And, even for all those people out there who know Google will probably unveil a brand new version of Android very soon, and even closer to the launch of the Galaxy S 4, none of that matters, either. They want the Galaxy S 4 because it has features, even if some folks out there are scratching their head at the price tag recently revealed by AT&T.

Android is a means to an end for these manufacturers. It isn’t a labor of love like iOS is for Apple, or like BlackBerry 10 is for BlackBerry.. Or any of the other companies out there bringing new software platforms to the fore. I'm not saying that HTC or Samsung don't put a ridiculous amount of work into Android, just that they've got efforts in other platforms, too. Especially Samsung, and their upcoming Tizen OS.

None of this is a bad thing, though. It’s a good thing that Samsung can find such popularity and success from Android, and the same goes for Amazon. (And hopefully it works out for HTC this year, too.) The point I’m trying to make is that maybe we shouldn’t even pay any attention to which version of Android a phone is running anymore, as long as it isn’t already ancient. So, nothing Android 4.0 or lower, obviously. Maybe we should just be calling it like it is: The HTC One is running Sense; the Galaxy S 4 is running TouchWiz, and so on and so forth.

Those are, after all, the differentiating factors, are they not? That’s how Samsung and HTC break away from the pack. It’s how you know a Samsung device from an HTC handset. Not the version of Android, but which proprietary software is right there staring you in the face. So, just call it like you see it. Unless you refuse to use anything other than a Nexus-branded device, that is. Then obviously you should be upset if your phone isn’t getting updates in a timely manner. (Verizon’s Galaxy Nexus LTE, am I right?)

After all, it’s not going to matter which version of Android a new “Facebook phone” might be running. It’s just going to matter how customized it is. Are we looking at an Amazon-level of custom kit? Or more like a new HTC One? Guess we’ll find out.

So what do you think? Do you care at all which version of Android your device is running, as long as it isn’t ancient and unable to run your favorite apps? Do you think smartphone manufacturers with their own software should just make a point to announce which version of their own software they’re running, instead of making a big deal about Android version? Let me know.


Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts


Products mentioned in this Article



eBay prices for the Samsung Galaxy S 4 Black Mist 16GB


Related posts



Comments & discussions  

24 Reactions to this post

"Have we reached a point where the version of Android on your device just doesn't matter anymore, thanks to manufacturers using proprietary software so heavily?"


Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Add
Thanks for your participation! :)

Anonymous
Anonymous No. Every version of Android brings refined drivers and different integration that make use of ur phones' hardware better. So yeah Android version is important ( Minor update isn't though )
Kelly Tanaka
Kelly Tanaka Yes.
Jose Mojica
Jose Mojica IOS doesn't need to catch up. These updates are aren't adding much these days. Or they are just not much you are going to use. We need more hardware innovation. Nokia seems to be raising the bar in that area so others should be catching up soon. Seems like HTC is trying but Samsung seems to happy because people are just gonna wanna get a galaxy device. I would get the one before the S4. Lets be honest these phones pretty much have all the features we need in terms of software. For it to get better they need to make hardware advances. Lets see what Nokia does this year to push the bar again.
Jeff Seaver
Jeff Seaver It does matter. Android getting better by each newer version. Not giving chance for iOS to catch up
Vicente Reyes
Vicente Reyes Updates matter, UI overlays suck.
Carl Dale
Carl Dale I got 4.0.3. I want to have jb (sensation xe) but if not , then I won't whine like the rest of the android community
Shafii Sigera
Shafii Sigera It does matter
Mark Belkowski
Mark Belkowski of course it matters. thats why android is fragmented. we all should be on at least 4.2. older phones excluded of course.
Gabriel Fernandez
Gabriel Fernandez No.
Jonathan Coffey
Jonathan Coffey I disagree with so this article is telling us 1.5 Cupcake is equal to 4.2 Jellybean . LOL I disagree
Taz Dhaliwal
Taz Dhaliwal Nexus ftw
Reese Woodson
Reese Woodson I have a 16GB Nexus 4; so I'm good to go with updates/ latest version of Android.
Lance Hill
Lance Hill If the updates where ONLY new features but they come with bug fixes too. Android 4.0 cut my battery life in half and when Android 4.1 finally got to my original droid razr maxx my battery life went back to normal but by that time I already bought an IPhone 5 and the updates for IOS came flooding in. Love it.
Samuel Cummings
Samuel Cummings In a lot of ways, yep. That's why I try to use phones with only vanilla Android on them, or root them.
Shawn Dulin
Shawn Dulin Rooting makes everything better
Roger DeOliveira
Roger DeOliveira just feels better knowing im on the highest level possible since i use a nexus
Matthew Hessler
Matthew Hessler It's absurd. It's one of the many reasons I'd only ever buy a Nexus device- Guaranteed updates, no BS. Google releases features and updates as they like, while phone manufacturers will intentionally hold back updates because they want to bastardize and rebrand Google's new features as their own to sell their newest phone and screw you, the customer, who just got yours less than a year ago.
Vikas Nanda
Vikas Nanda Surely it depends on the features introduced with the update ie. Google Now is only available on devices with jelly bean and above...
Nick Petrizzio
Nick Petrizzio Blame the carriers for all of this
Justin Charles Reback
Justin Charles Reback Sometimes, yes. But there are also enhancements at the core of the software with some updates(eg, Project Butter in 4.1) where if the phone or device running Android isn't running version x, it may not be up to snuff. I've heard from some that they like the Kindle Fire HD but they find that it's pretty slow sometimes. Not a fan of these devices where they skin the hell out of it to the point where it's not even Android, and not really that open either.
Jeff Jones
Jeff Jones Uh, no. Quite the opposite. Sick of manufactures/carriers who think we only deserve 1 to maybe 2 updates. It should be updated for the length of the contract.
Alvin Advocat?
Alvin Advocat? totally agree I have gingerbread :)
Dwayne Cook
Dwayne Cook Yeah... I will never go below 4.1. Anything below is obsolete.
Haldi Kuniqi
Haldi Kuniqi actually it does ill never use any android version below 4.1




Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings


See all hot devices