As “upgrade day” for me gets closer by the minute, I’ve been ramping up my research for what phone would work best for me. I’ve been torn between several models for quite some time now, and it’s not getting any easier as there is still two months left before I can officially decide – plenty of time for some new device to pop up to change my opinion. However, for the moment I’m focusing in on which features I would like to have for my next “it” phone, and lately I’ve been doing a lot of research on camera qualities.

One of the most important features to me in a phone is the camera. I’ve gone from carrying my phone plus a digital camera to, for the most part, only carrying my phone with me (except on special occasions). We have certainly come a long way from the days where 2 megapixels was considered “amazing” in cell phones: we had 3.2 megapixels, 5 megapixels, and 8 megapixels. When the Nokia Lumia 920 debuted with its PureView camera technology, the smartphone camera world was fascinated at how well the pictures turned out compared to competitors. The Lumia’s camera was what initially got me to take a second look at Windows Phone at all.

But as with all mobile technology, anything “new” only has a matter of months (sometimes weeks) before it is outdone by something else, and would seem like the ever-fantastic Lumia 920 camera is moving over in favor of cameras that come in the form of 13-megapixel and UltraPixel variety.

Or is it?

I was just reading a comparison from Digital Photography Review Connect, a photography review website, regarding the camera qualities of the Samsung Galaxy S 4, the HTC One, the iPhone 5, and the Nokia Lumia 920. I find it interesting seeing the opinions of professional photographers compared to average, run-of-the-mill users like myself. I really enjoy reading about mobile camera comparisons, but before I actually read the article I like to look at the image comparisons and make conclusions for myself. It becomes abundantly clear that I am no photography professional as every time I compare my conclusions with the professionals my opinions always clash. Then again, I’m sure how people determine “good image quality” is different from user to user – kind of like how we view smartphones. One person can love Android while another lives and breathes for Windows Phone. It’s very much a personal opinion type of deal.

Without delving too much into the Connect article, the basis of the post says that each device essentially performs worse than a good compact camera, but each still has its good components – for the most part.

Conclusively, the Galaxy S 4 performs the best in well-lit situations and provides the most clarity as you blow up the photos; the HTC One is the new king when it comes to low-lit environments (taking over for the Nokia Lumia 920); and the iPhone still does an okay job but doesn’t really have anything that stands out about it. The Nokia Lumia received an iffy overall standing, something that I was very surprised to read about as my opinions on the Lumia’s camera were very different than that of the professionals who wrote the article.

I agree that the Galaxy S 4 performed very well in well-lit situations and appeared the best when cropped, and I also agree that HTC is really doing something by opting to go for better sensors rather than building into the megapixel hype (but it does show how little detail some photos can display compared to the Galaxy S 4); the low-light photos from the One really stand out compared to other cameras. As for the iPhone 5, comparatively speaking I agree that there is nothing wonderful about the camera but I am surprised that they essentially placed it over the Nokia Lumia’s camera quality. It may be a little over contrasted but I tend to favor photos with higher saturation and contrast over those that look washed out – but that’s just me. After reading several camera reviews I have come to realize that my view of a “good image” is probably skewed from my teenage days where filters, brightness, and contrast were just being discovered – and we used them all the time. I still use them. I can’t help but to favor them, so it makes sense that I favor the Lumia 920’s over-contrasted camera compared to the iPhone’s 5 more natural lighting.

I am not one to argue with a professional, and I found the review very extensive and enjoyable to read. On the professional side of things, it was probably the best mobile phone camera review I’ve ever come across. But that’s where the point of my post comes in. Each camera does have something different to offer, and if you’re planning on using your phone as a camera then it’s best to find out for yourself exactly which camera would work best for you. Are you often in a low-lit environment? Do you plan on blowing your pictures up? Do you prefer natural lighting over higher contrasted photos? All of these questions are important aspects to look for when deciding on which camera would be best for you in a mobile device.

So readers, now it’s your turn. What is the most important quality to you in a mobile phone camera? Out of all of the devices out right now, do you have a favorite? Let me know your thoughts in the comments!


Images via Digital Photography Review Connect, The Verge

Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Products mentioned in this Article

eBay prices for the HTC One Black 32GB

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

49 Reactions to this post

"Out of all phones on the market right now, which one has your vote for best camera?"

Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Thanks for your participation! :)

Darren Tan Professional reviews be darned, I love the contrast on my 920, and the unnaturally bright night shots.
Jeff Cross Clearly the winner is the SG4 for overall performance I read the article
Paul Alexandru iPhone 4S-5
John Agzarian Lumia 920
Kevin Joel Lumia 920
Philip Lu Stop posting fake videos BG Michael, that LG Optimus G vs HTC One video is definitely not real. How can you put LG Optimus G's name on HTC One's video and vice versa and expect people not to find out.
Philip Lu Ok, let's assume, 1. He holds hTC One in his right hand and LG Optimus G in his left all the way through this video. 2. At the very end of this video, where the cat was being compared, both of the phone was facing flat forward Then can someone tell me why: - The LG Optimus G phone which he held in his left hand cannot see the cat's face? Where as HTC One which he held in the right hand can see more of the cat's head and not its body?
Philip Lu Sorry but I really have doubts about this video
DeLeavelli DeLeon beside the sg4 the note 2
Shawn Gergler Out right now. Note 2
Danny Chavez Note II. Does everything I want it to and more
Devin Martinez Iphone 5
Christopher Manic Johnson The iPhone 5. I preach Android, but the iPhone's camera continues to amaze. The GS3's is still pretty solid
Brandon Johnson I don't have any of the phones I mentioned but I'll be jumping from my 4s back to android for the Htc one.
Brandon Johnson From the tests I've seen the phones with the best cameras right now, are the One, Iphone 5, and 920. (The pureview 404 probably has the best phone camera ever, but the phobe is weak).
Matt Pankey In my experience the HTC Amaze.
David Smith Sony experia
Vicki Figueroa If your phone didn't just get released then the one you own is hardly the best. Keep dreaming
Warren Saunders There can be only ONE........HTC ONE!!!
Huayuan Song The HTC One
Robert Salender 920. Final answer.
Steve Hirjak HTC ONE!
BG Michael http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_qkzYkEXKHs
Frank F. Bona The one i own.
Vicki Figueroa I can't stand when ppl say the best phone is the one you own... that's crap. There's always better phones coming out after you buy yours. The one I own is hardly the best phone cause its 2 years old. I'm upgrading next month to the S4 & that'll be the best phone for a minute until the next big thing is released. So that statement is completely untrue.
BG Michael http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPD_z93nG5I i like this kind of comparison.
Usama Nasim Daddy of all phones.... nokia pure view 808.... the 41 m.p shooter leaves everyone behind...... no one even comes close.....the quality is unbelievably great...... crystal clear
BG Michael http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wPD_z93nG5I LG Optimus G is more accurate and neutral brightness (TRUE TO LIFE COLOR)
Vicki Figueroa S4 is about to be out in s couple of days & it has a 13 megapixel camera so I'm gonna go with that one
Geoff Sauder iPhone 5
Youri Abas Nokia lumia 920
BG Michael http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GO9D4JqC7xo
BG Michael http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_qkzYkEXKHs
BG Michael http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IoLHQdAaFiU
BG Michael LG Optimus G
William Plotner lumia 920 or Htc One.
Joe Keener the phone you own of course ;)
Alex Villalpando i dont own one but the lumia pictures are amazing my friend sends me pics and im always amazed
Lawrence Lepes Galaxy S4
Said Issa I've used many htc phones and their camera isn't as good as my s3's.
Sergio Rubio Nokia Lumia 920
Dani Hayes Any Sony, Nokia, and iPhone 4S and 5.
Nathan Wright Its between the HTC One and iPhone 5 for me.

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices