Cell phones > Buying guide

Analog, Digital – Does it Matter?

PhoneDog LLC
Updated on Aug 22, 06
by PhoneDog LLC,
 Stay updated with our rss feeds on these topics
Whether it's on TV or in print, wireless service companies are constantly touting the advantages of their "100 Percent All-Digital Networks."  But what does that mean?  What's the big deal about digital, and is it really any different than analog cellular when it comes to your ability to place and receive phone calls and use data services?

Here's a look at where digital cellular — and its predecessor, analog — came from and where it's going.  Do you need digital now?  Are there actually advantages to analog?  Read on and find out.

Why Digital?

Digital is the future.  Almost all of the nationwide cellular carriers now use digital networks or are at the very least in the process of converting their networks from analog to digital.  Digital promises better service quality, enhanced security, and next-generation features including calling conveniences (call waiting, three-way calling, etc.), wireless data and multimedia services. For the most part, digital delivers, too. Digital handsets can also pack more features into a smaller and lighter package than their analog counterparts.

Operators like digital because it means a more efficient network capable of carrying more data (voice calls plus other services) for a lower operational cost.  Consumers like digital because it generally means better sound quality on voice calls and enhanced features and faster speeds on everything else from voicemail to cellular Internet services.  Digital's fans also claim that a digital network is a safer network, as digital signals can be scrambled upon transmission, making it harder for would-be thieves to steal users' personal information.

Why Analog?

Analog is certainly in its dying days of serving the cellular telephone users of the United States, but if you live or spend much time in certain areas not yet covered by digital networks (rural locales, mainly), you might want to consider a dual-mode phone that can switch from digital to analog as needed.

City dwellers and other cellular users who spend the majority of their time in areas covered by digital networks probably don't need to think twice about whether or not their phones are analog-compatible.  Digital isn't going anywhere soon, and when its time inevitably does come it will be in favor of a new technology and not analog.  For the time being, analog is a handy backup if you live or often travel to rural, coastal, or other areas on the fringes of digital cellular networks.  Otherwise, there's no real need to worry about getting an analog phone.

Next Page - Cellular Marketing Strategies

eric s.
Tuesday, July 22, 2008Which firm would you go with for a two week GSM phone rental for use in Japan, with v/mail, calling to and from U.S.?
bev Chirhart
Thursday, July 17, 2008Is there any plan that does not require a two year contract to start service. I have t-mobile, my contract is running out, but I am upset with the service we have had and don't want to have to commit to another two years, tho I can't seem to find a plan that works better for us
Beth Bacon
Wednesday, July 16, 2008I lost my ATT (GSM) phone and would like to buy a replacement so that I do not have to extend my existing phone plan. Because my phone is lost (fell in the bay), I cannot exchange the SIM card. Can I still buy a replacement phone with this plan?
apondi christine
Friday, July 11, 2008this is informative1! can i have it please?
Michelle -
Thursday, June 26, 2008Thanks for the good information on Insurance.. I thought I was the only one who thought it was nuts, but I never realized it was that bad. I think a manufacturer's warranty is good enough for me, but the Ebay idea is really smart!
Benedicto Phiri
Tuesday, June 17, 2008This is a fantastic example of B2C ebusiness for sure i have liked it.
beth sanders
Monday, June 16, 2008major complaint with t-mobile: just thursday night i recieved 4 messages from monday 1 from my childs school telling me they are letting the kids out early-make sure someone is home 1 from a client waiting to see a house (i'm a realtor) 2 from banks concerning another deal all very important- all making me look incompetant and this is not the first time
Syira Saad
Friday, May 30, 2008how to delete exceed of web sessions in Motorola L6
Timothy Carpenter
Thursday, May 22, 2008I have a Southern Linc model i355 motorola phone. I was told my sim card would not fit in a nextel phone. Is this true?
bill townley
Monday, May 19, 2008i have Alltel service and would like a new phone. I don't believe the AudioVox phone CDM 8910 that I have has a sim card. What can I do?
betty williamson
Tuesday, May 13, 2008I have a account with suncom and am in need of an another phone.I like this one. How can I purchase one and how much?

Add a comment

Are you a real person? We just want to make sure...
Please enter the 6 characters seen in the image below
Anti-spam image

Don't forget to submit your entry for the "PhoneDog Days of Summer" Giveaway!
Win one of over 30 of the hottest new cell phones - no registration, no spam! Just PhoneDog sharing some goodies with our visitors & loyal fans! Thanks and keep the comments coming!


Latest Videos & Reviews

Check out the latest cell phone videos and in-depth reviews from Noah and our other expert editors
  • Video: Instinct vs iphone 3g vs Dare vs Treo 800w: Speed Test
    Speed Test Pt 2Another Internet speed test pitting four 3G phones against one another. The takeaway? 3G coverage
  • Video: Instinct vs iPhone 3G - Web and Speed Test
    Instinct vs iPhone Speed VideoNoah puts Instinct and iPhone 3G head-to-head in a Web and speed battle. First is a raw download
  • Video: iPhone 3g Review: Free SMS and AIM Instant Messaging
    iPhone AIM and Free SMSNoah continues looking at the new iPhone 3G. In this video it's IMing using the AIM app, which is
  • Video: iPhone 3g Review: App Store, Pt 2
    iPhone 3g Review Pt 2The big news with the new iPhone is price, 3G, and the App Store. Noah takes a look at Super Monkey
  • Video: LG Dare vs Samsung Instinct - PhoneDog Dogfight
    LG Dare vs Samsung InstinctTwo of the Summer's hottest touchscreen phones go head to head. LG Dare for Verizon vs Samsung
  • Video: iPhone 3g Review: App Store, Pt 1
    iPhone 3g Review Pt 1The big news with the new iPhone is price, 3G, and the App Store. Noah takes a look at installing
  • Video: iPhone 3g Unboxing and Hands-On
    iPhone 3g UnboxingPart one of our extensive coverage of Apple's new iPhone 3G. Noah brings you an unboxing,
  • Video: iPhone 3G - At the Launch
    iPhone 3G - At the LaunchLive from the iPhone 3G launch. Folks started lining up at 3AM here at the AT&T store in Berkeley,
  • Video:  LG Chocolate 3 (VZW) Unboxing and Hands-On
    Video: LG Chocolate 3Update: $129 after rebate with two-year contract, available Sunday July 13 The heat's getting
  • Video:  Motorola ROKR E8 (T-Mobile) Unboxing and Hands-On
    Video: Motorola ROKR E8ROKR you like a Hurricane. Moto's new ROKR E8 features a morphing keypad, touch sensitive nav
  • LG Dare
    LG DareWhat’s Good: Attractive, highly customizable UI with home screen shortcuts; Compact design with
  • Samsung Instinct-M800
    Samsung Instinct-M800What’s Good: Supports every feature Sprint offers; EV-DO Rev. A data speeds; Good touchscreen
  • LG enV2
    LG enV2What’s Good: Sleeker and smaller than the original EnV. Comfortable QWERTY keyboard and QVGA
  • Motorola Z9
    Motorola Z9What’s Good: Great voice quality; fast 3G data speeds; good GPS system; mobiTV compatibility;
  • Samsung Glyde
    Samsung GlydeWhat’s Good: Touchscreen and Full QWERTY Keyboard in Compact Body; Clean Menus and “Croix” User
  • Nokia N82
    Nokia N82What’s Good: Incredible Camera w/Xenon Flash; Full VGA Video Capture; Excellent Web Browser; WiFi;
  • BlackBerry Pearl-8120 Titanium
    BlackBerry Pearl-8120 TitaniumWhat’s Good: Integrated WiFi for Web, Email, and HotSpot@Home UMA Calling; Trackball is easy to
  • LG Venus
    LG VenusWhat’s Good: Beautiful display; Context-sensitive menus; Extensive feature set; VZ Navigation works
  • Nokia N810 Silver
    Nokia N810 SilverWhat’s Good: Stylish, compact design with large touchscreen and full QWERTY keyboard; Excellent
  • LG Rumor White
    LG Rumor WhiteWhat’s Good: Compact, rugged design with full QWERTY keyboard; Easy to use; Auto-rotating display;

New & coming soon phones

Hot off the presses... here's what's available now and expected to come to market soon!
  • LG Chocolate-3-VX8560 Black
    LG Chocolate-3-VX8560 BlackCarrier: Verizon Wireless
    Contract Price: $179.99
    Hot Feature: Sleek flip phone Coco
  • Samsung Blackjack-2-SGH-617 Blue
    Samsung Blackjack-2-SGH-617 BlueCarrier: AT&T
    Contract Price: Free
    Hot Feature: New color - Blue
  • Samsung Blackjack-2-SGH-617 Pink
    Samsung Blackjack-2-SGH-617 PinkCarrier: AT&T
    Contract Price: Free
    Hot Feature: New color - Pink
  • Nokia 2760
    Nokia 2760Carrier: T-Mobile
    Contract Price: Free
    Hot Feature: FM Radio
  • Palm Treo 800w
    Palm Treo 800wCarrier: Sprint
    Contract Price: $349.99 pre-rebate
    Hot Features: GPS Nav, WiFi, more
  • Apple iPhone 3G Black 8GB
    Apple iPhone 3G Black 8GBCarrier: AT&T
    Contract Price: $199.99
    Hot Feature: 3G for iPhone
  • Motorola ROKR-E8
    Motorola ROKR-E8Carrier: T-Mobile
    Contract Price: $249.99 before rebate
    Hot Feature: "ModeShift" technology
  • LG AX300
    LG AX300Carrier: Alltel
    Contract Price: $20 with instant rebate
    Hot Feature: Small compact design
  • LG Decoy VX8610
    LG Decoy VX8610Carrier: Verizon Wireless
    Contract Price: $99.99
    Hot Feature: Integrated Bluetooth headset
  • LG Dare
    LG DareCarrier: Verizon Wireless
    Contract Price: $199.99 - after online discount
    Hot Feature: I-phone competitor
More latest releases
More coming soon phones