More Android?...check out DroidDog.com for Android related news, videos, discussions and more

Play the One-Paw Bandit!

Lawsuits, pt deux: Nokia claims Apple violated 10 patents

Lawsuits, pt deux: Nokia claims Apple violated 10 patents
Posted Thursday, October 22, 2009 by Adriana Lee     
Views: 4722

Is this peak litigation season or something? After the news broke that AT&T is suing LCD manufacturers, there’s word that Nokia has just filed a lawsuit against Apple in Delaware today. The Finnish company is claiming that the iPhone has violated 10 of the Finnish company’s GSM, UMTS and Wifi patents.

Says Nokia (via press release): “The patents cover wireless data, speech coding, security and encryption and are infringed by all Apple iPhone models shipped since the iPhone was introduced in 2007.” According to the litigant, roughly 40 other companies (“virtually all the leading mobile device vendors”) license these patents, which cover key technologies that make GSM phones work. Apple, however, refused to come to “appropriate” licensing terms for its mobile device.

So what does “appropriate” mean? No idea. But it’s not hard to imagine Cupertino blustering in and trying to set its own terms, or batting the issue away like a pesky mosquito and ignoring the patents completely. When it comes to Apple (whose products, btw, I adore, but whose attitude drives me nuts), lawsuits are just par for the course. This isn’t the first time the company’s been sued, and it probably won’t be the last. But does this case actually have any legs?

Nokia hasn’t actually come out and announced what specific damages it’s seeking, so I wonder what would happen if it actually wins. Guesses, anyone?

[via Phone Scoop, Engadget Mobile]

Follow me on twitter
Adriana  Lee
Adriana Lee - Mobile lifestyle editor / iPhone editor
Adriana Lee, a journalist and admitted gadget freak, has covered everything from business and tech trends to fashion and pop culture. Published in consumer and trade titles, she’s been showing...

Sponsored Links

  • LG Shine II
    LG Shine IICarrier: AT&T Retail Price: $169.99 Contract Price: $119.99 Hot Features: 2MP auto-focus...
  • BlackBerry Bold 9700 for AT&T
    BlackBerry Bold 9700 for AT&TCarrier: AT&T Retail Price: $299.99 Contract Price: $199.99 Hot Features: Great QWERTY...
  • Pantech Impact
    Pantech ImpactCarrier: AT&T Retail Price: $149.99 Contract Price: $99.99 Hot Features: 3G data, GPS, 2MP...
  • Nokia 2720
    Nokia 2720Carrier: T-Mobile Retail Price: $69.99 Contract Price: $19.99 Hot Features: 1.3MP camera with...
  • BlackBerry Curve 8530
    BlackBerry Curve 8530Carrier: Verizon Wireless Retail Price: $199.99 Contract Price: $99.99 Hot Features: 2.0MP...
More latest releases »

Comments on this Article

Profile image icon for ~ceaser28
~ceaser28 @ Oct 22 5:53 PM
well double jeopardy is sueing someone for the same thing, so its not hard to take someone to court over similar things just not the same exact thing, but apple has been dodging alot of things since its launch with the iphone which is (only speculation) part of the reason the iphone and verizon had issues when apple tried to go with them first before AT&T
Profile image icon for kalebman6969
kalebman6969 @ Oct 22 2:07 PM
i think that nokia should sue apple. My case hasnt hit headlines yet but i hope it does. im sueing apple for giving out my personal info that i had on my ipod touch. i had everything from things i bought to the amount of cash in my bank account. so hopefully some people will see this and support me. i dont want apple doing the same to other iphone ipod touch or mac users.
Profile image icon for circles927
circles927 @ Oct 22 2:13 PM
that's crazy! how do you know they gave out your info?
also, all due resect but why would you keep that stuff on a ipod?
more times then none the network used for wireless devices aren't secure. i.e., anyone can get at it.
Profile image icon for circles927
circles927 @ Oct 22 1:49 PM
the iphone has been out for how long now?
and nokia is just now taking apple to court?
something's wrong here.
Profile image icon for Mirror0423
Mirror0423 @ Oct 22 4:08 PM
I phone has TONS of "neat little things" it can do. I'm sure the people at Nokia wanted to find everything they could to sue them. You know with the double jeopardy and all (not sure how that works but seems like it could apply?), and not to mention the hassle of suing a company as big as apple multiple times. Better to do it once and do it right than to sue them multiple times for little nit picky things. Cause 10 nit picky things is an actual case o_O
Profile image icon for stalllion1
stalllion1 @ Oct 22 4:29 PM
i know i think nokia is trying to get back in the spotlight

Add a comment

Your comments:
E-Mail me when someone replies to this comment