Play the One-Paw Bandit!

Apple iPhone Review - Conclusion



Details

W/new plan

W/family plan

Prepaid

Phone only

Used

    Specs   Images   Expert reviews   User reviews   Manual   Compare   Accessories   Mobile Content

Noah Kravitz
Posted on Monday, October 08, 2007
by Noah Kravitz, Editor in Chief, PhoneDog Media
Share/Save/Bookmark

Conclusion

Editor Rating: 4.7
5 
5 
I could write for days about iPhone only to find that both Apple and independent developers had extended the handset's functionality significantly while I was locked away with my word processor. Suffice it to say that iPhone is as much a mobile entertainment, communications, and personal data device as it is a cell phone. In fact, it's the basic cell phone functions that iPhone is worst at. Calls and ringtones are too quiet, there's no voice dialing, and making a call is often a multiple click process that involves pressing the Home button, touching the Phone icon, touching the Keypad icon, and then dialing the number on the touch screen.

Beyond that, iPhone's advanced functionality is hampered by EDGE-only access to data networks, a lack of stereo Bluetooth or any kind of Bluetooth profiles for exchanging files, no flash for the camera, no external media controls, a bizarrely designed audio jack that's forced many an iPhone user to take an X-Acto knife to his favorite earphones, and a sealed-up back panel that means if you drain your battery before you can make it back home or to the hotel, you're out of luck. A non-user replaceable battery means carrying a spare on your next business trip will do you no good at all.

That being said, iPhone is the closest thing to a perfect mobile device I've ever tried. I hesitated before writing that sentence, and I'm grimacing now that I'm tapping it out, but I'm pretty certain it's true bearing in mind that my wants for a mobile device may be quite different from your own. iPhone's industrial design, amazingly useable display, and intuitive user interface puts it ahead of SuperPhone competitors like the Helio Ocean, Nokia N95, and BlackBerry Curve when it comes my particular preferences. Ocean's got a physical QWERTY board and 3G data, N95's got a 5 MP camera, GPS and 3G data, and Curve's got a QWERTY board and BlackBerry email - those are features I wish iPhone had, and they're on fantastic devices that many people will choose over iPhone for those (and other) specific reasons. But in terms of combining a foward-looking feature set with innovative extras, a great form factor, and menus that make sense, nothing can top iPhone right now.

iPhone is frustrating because it so clearly could be so much more. And it's extra frustrating because as I'm writing this, Apple just mounted a counter-offensive against an open source community that came together specifically to make iPhone as "much more" as possible. Still, Apple has made an outstanding product. If you need a phone that makes phone calls and not much else, iPhone is not for you. If you're interested in a phone that can access Web and email, and maybe play music or videos, manage your calendar, and let you carry some photos around (and really, most mid-to-high end handsets these days do these things), iPhone is well worth a look. At $599 I thought it was over-priced. At $399 (or the $299 I paid for the now defuct 4GB model), it's right on par with other high-end models, and it simply blows them away when it comes to Web browsing and playing music, videos, and photos.

iPhone has the potential to be the beginning of a full-on "mobile communicator" platform that could cause Apple to literally revolutionize the ways in which we compute and communicate - and to inspire Apple's competitors to up their own level of innovation. Here's hoping that this first release - which is already a pretty amazing product - in fact proves to be only the beginning of something really, really good.

Compare prices »

Fetch me more...

Quickly jump to more information about related topics, cell phones, carriers or phone manufacturers mentioned in this In-Depth Review by using the links below.
Companies: Apple

About our in-depth cell phone reviews

We take great pride to ensure that the our reviews are thorough and accurate. In no way are our editors directed or influenced by any manufacturers, advertisers, or partners; we believe that honest, opinionated reviews -positive or negative - are the only way to maintain credibility and serve our users.

Reviews by company

Apple,   BenQ,   BlackBerry,   Eten,   HTC,   LG,   Motorola,   Nokia,   o2,   Palm,   Pantech,   Samsung,   Sanyo,   Sharp,   Sony Ericsson


Latest cell phone reviews

  • BlackBerry Storm2
    BlackBerry Storm2 9550 What's Good: Screen is far easier to use thanks to the addition of electronic sensors; OS 5.0
  • BlackBerry Bold 9700
    BlackBerry Bold 9700What's Good: Significantly improved design over the original Bold, fantastic keyboard, great
  • LG Glance Expert Review by Aaron
    LG GlanceWhat's Good: Durable device with good call quality and strong battery life. What's Bad: No 3G;
  • Johns Samsung Omnia HD (i8910) review
    Samsung Omnia HD i8910John loves the screen, but does the software justify this phone's great looks?
  • Motorola Clutch i465
    Motorola Clutch i465What's Good: Call quality; fantastic speakerphone. What's Bad: Battery life; somewhat cramped
  • LG LX290
    LG LX290What's Good: Build quality; fantastic reception; battery life is respectable. What's Bad: No EVDO;
  • Nokia Twist 7705
    Nokia Twist 7705What's Good: Unique design; phenomenal QWERTY keyboard. What's Bad: Battery life could be better;
  • HTC Hero, CDMA (Sprint)
    HTC Hero CDMAJohn takes an in-depth look at Sprint's chinless HTC Hero.
  • Samsung Highlight
    Samsung Highlight T749 FireThe Samsung Highlight is a slim touch screen cell phone that has a lot going for it: 3G
  • Samsung Instinct HD
    Samsung Instinct HDWhat's Good: Nice design, complete with HD video-out for digital media fans. What's Bad: Some lag

Latest cell phone videos

New & coming soon phones

Hot off the presses... here's what's available now and expected to come to market soon!
  • Pantech C630
    Pantech C630 Carrier: AT&T
    Retail Price:$129.99 or via Ebay
    Contract Price:$39.99 or via Lets Talk
    Hot Feature 3G Candybar Phone
  • LG Rhythm-UX585
    LG Rhythm-UX585 Carrier: U.S. Cellular
    Retail Price:$279.95
    Contract Price:$79.95
    Hot Feature: Slider+ 1" touch screen
  • Motorola Hint QA30
    Motorola Hint QA30 Carrier: Alltel
    Retail Price:$299.99
    Contract Price:$99.99
    Hot Feature: Slider with full QWERTY
  • HTC Touch Pro Verizon
    HTC Touch Pro VerizonCarrier: Verizon
    Retail Price:$539.99 or via ebay
    Contract Price:$349.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: Touchscreen+ Full QWERTY
  • Samsung Omnia
    Samsung Omnia Carrier: Verizon
    Retail Price:$ TBD
    Contract Price:$249.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: Full Touchscreen + 5MP Cam
  • BlackBerry Storm
    BlackBerry StormCarrier: Verizon
    Retail Price:$519.99 or via ebay
    Contract Price:$199.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: "SurePress" Touchscreen
  • Samsung Renown
    Samsung Renown Carrier: Verizon
    Retail Price:$349.99 or via ebay
    Contract Price:$179.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: 2.0 MP camera
  • LG Incite
    LG InciteCarrier: AT&T
    Retail Price: $499.99 or via ebay
    Contract Price:$299.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: LG's 1st US Smartphone
  • Samsung Gravity T459
    Samsung Gravity T459 Carrier: Tmobile
    Retail Price: TBD or via ebay
    Contract Price: 49.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: Full QWERTY
  • Samsung Eternity a867
    Samsung Eternity a867Carrier: AT&T
    Retail Price:$369.99 or via ebay
    Contract Price:$149.99 or via Let's Talk
    Hot Feature: Full Touch Screen + Mobile TV

Latest phone images

Omnia II SCH-i920Shine IIImpact BlueImpact Soft PinkCurve 8530 Smoky Violet2720Crush3711Helix UX310 OrangeTap BerryTap Midnight BlueFlight GreyMythic SGH-A897Flight RedHD2Convoy

One-Paw Bandit is finally here!

Dont' miss your chance to play our new instant-win game - PhoneDog's One-Paw Bandit. We're giving away the hottest phones, including iPhones, iPod touch, G1's and many more devices to come... - Play Today!

Fetch PhoneDog via Rss

Subscribe & use your favorite news reader to get: