Play the One-Paw Bandit!

BenQ P50 Review - Introduction & Design



Details

W/new plan

W/family plan

Prepaid

Phone only

Used

    Specs   Images   Expert reviews   User reviews   Manual   Compare   Accessories   Mobile Content

Noah Kravitz
Posted on Friday, August 18, 2006
by Noah Kravitz, Editor in Chief, PhoneDog Media
Share/Save/Bookmark

Introduction & Design

Editor Rating: 3.5
3 
3 
Half phone, half PDA, with some laptop functionality thrown in for good measure, the Benq P50 is the mobile executive's dream, at least on paper.  Combining a quad-band GSM cell phone, Windows Mobile-powered PDA with QWERTY keyboard and touchscreen display, and Wi-Fi enabled Web and Email capabilities into a handheld unit is no easy task.  Was Benq up to challenge when it designed the P50?  Yes ... and No.

Benq P50
The P50 has been called a "Treo knockoff," and while its screen-over-keyboard layout and overall dimensions are reminiscent of the Treo 650, to me it has something of a unique look and feel.  At 122 x 60 x 20 mm and weighing 5.3 oz, the P50 is no featherweight, but it is quite comfortable to use and surprisingly well-suited to one-handed operation.

Housed in dark grey plastic, the P50's looks belie its all-business attitude.  A 2.8" (diagonal) screen takes up roughly the top two-thirds of the front panel, with the bottom third given over to a row of silver controls - four soft keys flanking a center joystick - and an all-grey 39-button QWERTY keyboard below that.  The alphanumeric keys are labeled in silver, with dual-function buttons sporting orange numeric labels as well.  All front-panel buttons are backlit for better visibility during use.  Two LEDs in the top right corner of the front panel provide battery and connectivity feedback, and small slits for the speaker (top) and microphone (bottom) are visible as well.

The phone lacks the scroll wheel found on some PDA phones, but this does make it equally suited to left- or right-handed users.  Instead, a stylus that serves as the key to touchscreen functionality slides away into a holder molded into the upper right corner of the phone's back panel.  I found the included metal and plastic stylus to be quite comfortable to hold and use.  A rather large housing for the phone's 1.3 megapixel camera sensor takes up the top portion of the rear panel, and virtually the rest of the back is alloted to the 1240 mAh Li-On battery that powers the device. 

A silver rocker switch for volume and one programmable soft key are found on the left edge of the P50, as is the battery lock switch. The right edge of the phone houses a dedicated camera key as well as the USB and headphone jacks, which are concealed by a rubber cover tethered to the body of the phone for safekeeping.  The top panel of the handset has a single power button and an infrared port, while the bottom panel houses the AC adapter jack and SD/MMC memory card slot.

The overall look of the phone is business, business, business.  While certainly not unattractive, the P50 lacks the flash and pizzazz so common amongst today's hip new handsets.  Then again, the understated grey definitely carries some class with it.  As the P50 is only available in an unlocked version, no carrier symbols or other branding is present save for a silver Benq logo just below the screen.

As mentioned, while the P50 is on the larger end of the mobile phone scale, it's quite comfortable in hand during use.  Somewhat narrower and longer than competing devices like the T-Mobile MDA and Treo 600/650/700, the P50 felt very balanced in one hand during calls and stylus use.  The QWERTY keyboard was another story, however, as the narrow body necessitates keys too small and too closely packed together for comfortable use.  In fact, I wound up adopting a thumbnail-only technique on the keyboard since my thumb naturally spans two or three of the small, domed buttons. For the same reason, I also found myself using the virtual keypad on the touchscreen for phone dialing.  Seeing as the QWERTY board is a major draw to a device like the P50, the too-small buttons proved a major design flaw in my eyes.

Another note:  While many users will no doubt opt to leave the P50 tucked away in a pocket or case and use it for voice calls with a Bluetooth earpiece, I tested the phone primarily by holding it to my ear in the "conventional" manner.  Since the touchscreen stays in phone keypad mode during calls by default, this led to many inadvertent cheek-to-screen key presses which, in turn, led to many key tones rather annoyingly interrupting my conversations. 

Next: Features »

Fetch me more...

Quickly jump to more information about related topics, cell phones, carriers or phone manufacturers mentioned in this In-Depth Review by using the links below.
Companies: BenQ
Phones: BenQ P50

About our in-depth cell phone reviews

We take great pride to ensure that the our reviews are thorough and accurate. In no way are our editors directed or influenced by any manufacturers, advertisers, or partners; we believe that honest, opinionated reviews -positive or negative - are the only way to maintain credibility and serve our users.

Reviews by company

Apple,   BenQ,   BlackBerry,   Eten,   HTC,   LG,   Motorola,   Nokia,   o2,   Palm,   Pantech,   Samsung,   Sanyo,   Sharp,   Sony Ericsson


Latest cell phone reviews

  • LG Glance Expert Review by Aaron
    LG GlanceWhat's Good: Durable device with good call quality and strong battery life. What's Bad: No 3G;
  • Johns Samsung Omnia HD (i8910) review
    Samsung Omnia HD i8910John loves the screen, but does the software justify this phone's great looks?
  • Motorola Clutch i465
    Motorola Clutch i465What's Good: Call quality; fantastic speakerphone. What's Bad: Battery life; somewhat cramped
  • LG LX290
    LG LX290What's Good: Build quality; fantastic reception; battery life is respectable. What's Bad: No EVDO;
  • Nokia Twist 7705
    Nokia Twist 7705What's Good: Unique design; phenomenal QWERTY keyboard. What's Bad: Battery life could be better;
  • HTC Hero, CDMA (Sprint)
    HTC Hero CDMAJohn takes an in-depth look at Sprint's chinless HTC Hero.
  • Samsung Highlight
    Samsung Highlight T749 FireThe Samsung Highlight is a slim touch screen cell phone that has a lot going for it: 3G
  • Samsung Instinct HD
    Samsung Instinct HDWhat's Good: Nice design, complete with HD video-out for digital media fans. What's Bad: Some lag
  • Samsung Rogue SCH-u960
    Samsung Rogue SCH-u960What's Good: Absolutely stunning AMOLED screen, 3.5mm headphone jack instead of Samsung's
  • Samsung Comeback
    Samsung Comeback SGH-t559 Frost Silver CherryWith the wireless market becoming increasingly saturated, manufacturers are relying more and more

Latest cell phone videos

New & coming soon phones

Hot off the presses... here's what's available now and expected to come to market soon!
  • Motorola Droid
    Motorola DroidCarrier: Verizon Wireless
    Retail Price: $299.99
    Contract Price: $199.99
    Hot Features: Android OS, High-Res capacitive touchscreen, 5MP camera, slide-out full QWERTY keyboard
  • HTC Droid Eris
    HTC Droid ErisCarrier: Verizon Wireless
    Retail Price: $199.99
    Contract Price: $99.99
    Hot Features: Android OS, capacitive touchscreen, 5MP camera
  • LG Chocolate Touch
    LG Chocolate TouchCarrier: Verizon Wireless
    Retail Price: $129.99
    Contract Price: $79.99
    Hot Features: Touchscreen with vibrating response, 3.2MP camera
  • HTC Tilt 2
    HTC Tilt 2Carrier: AT&T
    Retail Price: $159.99
    Contract Price: $49.99
    Hot Features: 3.6" WVGA Touchscreen, 3.2MP camera, WiFi
  • Samsung Moment
    Samsung MomentCarrier: Sprint
    Retail Price: $479.99
    Contract Price: $179.99
    Hot Features: Touchscreen with slide-out QWERTY keyboard,GPS,SprintTV
  • Motorola CLIQ
    Motorola CLIQCarrier: T-Mobile
    Retail Price: $399.99
    Contract Price: $199.99
    Hot Features: Touchscreen with slide-out QWERTY, MOTOBLUR, WiFi
  • BlackBerry Storm2
    BlackBerry Storm2Carrier: Verizon Wireless
    Retail Price: $279.99
    Contract Price: $179.99
    Hot Features: SurePress™ touch screen technology, Pre-installed 16GB microSD card
  • Sony Ericsson Equinox
    Sony Ericsson EquinoxCarrier: T-Mobile
    Retail Price: $159.99
    Contract Price: $49.99
    Hot Features: Change your wallpaper themes to match your day or night time attire, Unique pulsating light effects
  • Samsung Caliber SCH-r850
    Samsung Caliber SCH-r850Carrier: U.S. Cellular
    Retail Price: $319.95
    Contract Price: $149.95
    Hot Features: 3.2" touchscreen display, full HTML Browser, 3MP camera
  • Samsung Trill SCH-r520
    Samsung Trill SCH-r520Carrier: U.S. Cellular
    Retail Price: $219.95
    Contract Price: $139.95
    Hot Features: 1.3MP camera,sound technology by Bang & Olufsen ICEpower

Latest phone images

HD2ConvoyChocolate TouchCurve 8530 BlackDroid ErisXperia X10MomentDroidEquinoxStorm2 9550Bold 9700Trill SCH-r520Caliber SCH-r850Exclaim M550 WhiteRumor 2 OrangeDebut i856

One-Paw Bandit is finally here!

Dont' miss your chance to play our new instant-win game - PhoneDog's One-Paw Bandit. We're giving away the hottest phones, including iPhones, iPod touch, G1's and many more devices to come... - Play Today!

Fetch PhoneDog via Rss

Subscribe & use your favorite news reader to get: