Play the One-Paw Bandit!

HTC G1 Review - Design & Features



Details

W/new plan

W/family plan

Prepaid

Phone only

Used

    Specs   Images   Expert reviews   User reviews   Manual   Compare   Accessories   Mobile Content

Noah Kravitz
Posted on Thursday, October 16, 2008
by Noah Kravitz, Editor in Chief, PhoneDog Media
Share/Save/Bookmark

Design & Features

Editor Rating: 4.5
3 
5 
G1 is big and bulky.  While the phone’s footprint is just a bit smaller than iPhone’s, its thickness really makes it feel like a brick in hand or pocket.  The flip-side is that the phone is quite solid.  From the touchscreen to the unique slider mechanism, I never once feared for G1’s safety. 

The phone features a 3.17” touchscreen with a full QWERTY thumbboard hidden underneath, and a trackball.  While this may sound like overkill in theory, in practice it’s great.  Sweeping across the touchscreen with my finger or thumb works like a charm, and the trackball lets me hone in on small Web links and buttons that have proved frustrating to click on other touchscreen phones I’ve tried. 

Noah Kravitz holding a T-mobile G1

G1 is available in Bronze and Black.  I got the Bronze version to review.  It’s pretty geeky looking, in all honesty, particularly given its size (relative to thinner, sleeker touchphones like iPhone and LG Dare), and the Jay Leno-esque chin that protrudes out at an angle at the bottom of the device.  Honestly, though, once you flip the thing on and the screen comes to life, you’ll forget about how little or much you like the way it looks when it’s off.

Android as a platform could really shake things up in the mobile world.  While G1’s feature set has a few glaring omissions, like no Stereo Bluetooth or Video capture or playback out of the box, the platform is meant to be built upon by developers.  There’s already a free Beta version of a video playback app in the Android Market, and I’d be shocked if Google doesn’t make sure that Market fills up good and fast with all sorts of nifty apps in the coming months.

As it is, Android’s excellent Web browser and Web-style Gmail integration (threaded conversations) take full advantage of the 802.11 WiFi radio and T-Mobile’s newly launched 3G network.  The device also features a 3MP camera with auto focus, and photo sharing is super-easy via Gmail or MMS messaging. 

While G1 lacks a video player out of the box, it does feature both an excellent YouTube client and a full-featured music player along with an Amazon mp3 app that allows for WiFi purchase and downloads of DRM-free music from the online retailer.  I bought a track for 99 cents and downloaded it via WiFi to the G1 with no problems.  While there’s no iTunes-style desktop app for syncing music, tracks are saved to a microSD card (a 1GB card is included) and can be transferred via card to your computer.

G1 also has a GPS chip that integrates very nicely with the onboard Google Maps application.  After a few false starts, GPS accuracy was quite good, and maps and directions loaded up lickety-split.  There’s no spoken turn-by-turn directions here like Sprint’s Instinct has, but the text/graphic directions were excellent.  G1’s compass mode ties the “Street View” of a map to the phone’s accelerometer, which makes for a fun way to explore your surroundings.

Next: Usability & Performance »

Fetch me more...

Quickly jump to more information about related topics, cell phones, carriers or phone manufacturers mentioned in this In-Depth Review by using the links below.
Topics: android,  g1
Phones: HTC G1,  HTC G1 White

About our in-depth cell phone reviews

We take great pride to ensure that the our reviews are thorough and accurate. In no way are our editors directed or influenced by any manufacturers, advertisers, or partners; we believe that honest, opinionated reviews -positive or negative - are the only way to maintain credibility and serve our users.

Reviews by company

Apple,   BenQ,   BlackBerry,   Eten,   HTC,   LG,   Motorola,   Nokia,   o2,   Palm,   Pantech,   Samsung,   Sanyo,   Sharp,   Sony Ericsson


Latest cell phone reviews

  • BlackBerry Storm2
    BlackBerry Storm2 9550 What's Good: Screen is far easier to use thanks to the addition of electronic sensors; OS 5.0
  • BlackBerry Bold 9700
    BlackBerry Bold 9700What's Good: Significantly improved design over the original Bold, fantastic keyboard, great
  • LG Glance Expert Review by Aaron
    LG GlanceWhat's Good: Durable device with good call quality and strong battery life. What's Bad: No 3G;
  • Johns Samsung Omnia HD (i8910) review
    Samsung Omnia HD i8910John loves the screen, but does the software justify this phone's great looks?
  • Motorola Clutch i465
    Motorola Clutch i465What's Good: Call quality; fantastic speakerphone. What's Bad: Battery life; somewhat cramped
  • LG LX290
    LG LX290What's Good: Build quality; fantastic reception; battery life is respectable. What's Bad: No EVDO;
  • Nokia Twist 7705
    Nokia Twist 7705What's Good: Unique design; phenomenal QWERTY keyboard. What's Bad: Battery life could be better;
  • HTC Hero, CDMA (Sprint)
    HTC Hero CDMAJohn takes an in-depth look at Sprint's chinless HTC Hero.
  • Samsung Highlight
    Samsung Highlight T749 FireThe Samsung Highlight is a slim touch screen cell phone that has a lot going for it: 3G
  • Samsung Instinct HD
    Samsung Instinct HDWhat's Good: Nice design, complete with HD video-out for digital media fans. What's Bad: Some lag

Latest cell phone videos


Latest phone images

Impact BlueImpact Soft PinkCurve 8530 Smoky Violet2720Crush3711Helix UX310 OrangeTap BerryTap Midnight BlueFlight GreyMythic SGH-A897Flight RedHD2ConvoyChocolate TouchCurve 8530 Black

One-Paw Bandit is finally here!

Dont' miss your chance to play our new instant-win game - PhoneDog's One-Paw Bandit. We're giving away the hottest phones, including iPhones, iPod touch, G1's and many more devices to come... - Play Today!

Fetch PhoneDog via Rss

Subscribe & use your favorite news reader to get: