Cell phones > Expert reviews > Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey

Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey Review - Display & Audio

Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey
Published on 10/15/2007
By: Noah Kravitz, Senior Editor, Consumer Products and Services
 Stay updated with our rss feeds on these topics
 
Editor Rating: 4.7
5 
4 
Though only 2” in size, the w580i’s display is big, bold, and bright - unless it’s in direct sunlight.  Capable of QVGA (320 x 240) resolution at 262,000 colors, the 580’s screen generally looks very good - all the more so because the phone’s user interface is such a pleasure to work with.  While confusing menus and hidden features are common complaints in the world of mobile phones, SE’s UI is refined and mature - both intuitive to use and easy on the eyes.

Icons, images, and videos all looked very nice on the w580i, and the included themes show off the phone’s capacity for displaying animated backgrounds.  The newest version of SE’s Walkman music player displays album art on the w580, and video files can be downloaded from the Internet or loaded onto an M2 memory stick card for playback on the handset as well.

Using the phone in bright, direct sunlight did prove to be a bit troublesome - perhaps just a bit more so than to be expected on a phone of this caliber.  Just to be sure my eyes weren’t playing tricks on me, I asked my wife if she’s had any trouble seeing the screen on her unlocked w580i.  She furrowed her brow for a second and replied, “Yeah, just a little sometimes when I’m outside.”

Sony Ericsson W580 audioI tested the quad-band GSM w580i on AT&T’s network in the San Francisco Bay Area of California, and my wife and I also tested the unlocked w850i on T-Mobile’s network in the same general locations.  While I ran into a few problems with interference and dropped calls on the AT&T version of the phone, we had no such issues with the unlocked version on T-Mobile.  So I’m pretty sure any calling problems I encountered were caused by AT&T’s network and not Sony Ericsson’s handset.

Audio quality during phone calls either good or riddled with problems.  Again, the problems seemed to stem from AT&T network coverage in specific locations (and at specific times), and not with the w580i.  When signals were solid, the handset was plenty loud and voices came through clearly with minimal interference on either end.  When problems occurred, I experienced everything from static and interference noise in the background to repeated call dropping.  The noise problems occurred whether I was using the earpiece, built-in speakerphone, wired headset or a wireless Bluetooth headset during calls.

Sony Ericsson included a Walkman music adapter and stereo canalphones in the w580i’s packaging.  The adapter snaps into the handset’s accessory port and features a 3.5mm stereo audio jack with an integrated microphone and single button for answering calls.  You can use the included earphones with the adapter, or connect your own ‘phones - while I’d prefer the headphone jack to have been built into the handset itself, at least SE includes an adapter (and better than average earphones) so you can use the Walkman features straight out of the box.  With a good pair of earphones and some tweaks to the EQ settings, the w580i sounds as good as most portable media players when playing back music.

The w580i’s built-in speaker is also quite loud.  Music, ringtones, and calls on speakerphone all rang out noticeably louder than they do on most handsets I’ve reviewed recently.  Stereo Bluetooth is also supported by the w580i, and music can be played and controlled via AD2P-compatible wireless headsets.  Certain SE Walkman-line Bluetooth headsets also support caller ID and music library browsing on the w580i via remote displays.

 

Next: Messaging, Internet & Connectivity »

Reviews by manufacturer

Verizon Wireless,   Sprint PCS,   Nokia,   Samsung,   Sony Ericsson,   Motorola,   LG,   Sanyo,   HTC,   Palm,   BlackBerry,   Sharp,   Pantech,   BenQ,   Apple,   Eten,   o2

Add a comment

There are two easy ways to submit your comment
  1. Sign in if you are already a member, or join PhoneDog for a free account- this way you won't have to re-enter your information on subsequent comment posts. Additionally you'll receive all these great benefits of being a PhoneDog community member.
    Or,
  2. Submit your comment without registering by using the form below

Don't forget to submit your entry for the "PhoneDog Days of Summer" Giveaway!
Win one of over 30 of the hottest new cell phones - no registration, no spam! Just PhoneDog sharing some goodies with our visitors & loyal fans! Thanks and keep the comments coming!

Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey in-depth review - Introduction and Design

Sony Ericsson W580i Introduction and Design
My wife has used a Samsung T809 ever since we signed a service contract a year and a half ago and she got one for free (after rebate, of course).  She really liked the phone's sleek slider profile, big, bold display, and overall cool factor.  Mind you, she's not a geek in any sense of the word - she's got style and so did her T809. But the T809 broke a few months ago and she'd been using one of my extras until the Sony Ericsson...

Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey in-depth review - Features

Sony Ericsson packed nearly all the features of its high-end k790/800 handsets into the w580i, making it a very versatile device for entertainment and communications purposes.  The 580’s interface, Web browser, RSS reader, email cilent, and file manager will all feel very familiar to users of these devices, but as a Walkman-branded device, the 580 also gets SE’s latest music player software.  As such, this is really a feature-packed...

Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey in-depth review - Messaging, Internet & Connectivity

For a consumer phone that doesn’t have a QWERTY board, the w580i’s messaging features are fairly robust.  The phone supports SMS and MMS messaging and POP/IMAP email via pre-installed software.  Messaging setup is fairly easy, and text, MMS, and Email messages are stored in separate mailboxes. The phone’s camera software makes it easy to take a photo and include it in an MMS or Email message, and video clips may also be attached to...

Sony Ericsson W580i Carbon Grey in-depth review - Conclusion

Sony Ericsson continues to make some of my favorite music and cameraphones, and the w580i brings a sense of style to their US market offerings.  This Walkman line handset offers one of the most complete out-of-the-box music phone experiences available this side of top of the line handsets costing hundreds of dollars more.  Between the refined user interface, included music adapter and stereo earphones, and 512 MB memory card, the w580i...

Latest Videos & Reviews

Check out the latest cell phone videos and in-depth reviews from Noah and our other expert editors
  • LG Dare
    LG DareWhat’s Good: Attractive, highly customizable UI with home screen shortcuts; Compact design with
  • Samsung Instinct-M800
    Samsung Instinct-M800What’s Good: Supports every feature Sprint offers; EV-DO Rev. A data speeds; Good touchscreen
  • LG enV2
    LG enV2What’s Good: Sleeker and smaller than the original EnV. Comfortable QWERTY keyboard and QVGA
  • Motorola Z9
    Motorola Z9What’s Good: Great voice quality; fast 3G data speeds; good GPS system; mobiTV compatibility;
  • Samsung Glyde
    Samsung GlydeWhat’s Good: Touchscreen and Full QWERTY Keyboard in Compact Body; Clean Menus and “Croix” User
  • Nokia N82
    Nokia N82What’s Good: Incredible Camera w/Xenon Flash; Full VGA Video Capture; Excellent Web Browser; WiFi;
  • BlackBerry Pearl-8120 Titanium
    BlackBerry Pearl-8120 TitaniumWhat’s Good: Integrated WiFi for Web, Email, and HotSpot@Home UMA Calling; Trackball is easy to
  • LG Venus
    LG VenusWhat’s Good: Beautiful display; Context-sensitive menus; Extensive feature set; VZ Navigation works
  • Nokia N810 Silver
    Nokia N810 SilverWhat’s Good: Stylish, compact design with large touchscreen and full QWERTY keyboard; Excellent
  • LG Rumor White
    LG Rumor WhiteWhat’s Good: Compact, rugged design with full QWERTY keyboard; Easy to use; Auto-rotating display;

New & coming soon phones

Hot off the presses... here's what's available now and expected to come to market soon!
More latest releases
More coming soon phones