Nokia 5800 XpressMusic Review Part 2

He's basically, "Here are my standards (based on the fact I think the iPhone is the best phone in the world), and this phone doesn't meet them."

That's not how to review a phone.

Everything "blows" with this guy. He's not reviewing this phone, he's criticizing it's differences. iPhone has a pretty UI, but took 3 generations to get a camcorder and cut/copy/paste, & a landscape virtual qwerty board, stuff this phone has out the box in generation one. God, I can't take Noah's reviews anymore.

Seems like this reviewer went into using the 5800 thinking it needs to be the second coming of the iPhone (like he thinks everything else with a touch screen should be). It's almost as though the reviewer seems to have gone into the review for this phone with his mind made up very early on. It's not the prettiest UI ever, I'll agree, but it's nothing you haven't seen before, despite the fact that that version of Symbian hadn't previously been made for touch screens. He made it seem like everything minor about the phone was so difficult and ill-designed, like how the browser didn't respond like the iPhone, how the UI isn't like the iPhone, how there's no kinetic scrolling like the iPhone, how it had a plastic resistive screen unlike the iPhone...

hey.. ive been using this hp and its great..... i adore noah but sometimes what he says isnt exactly true u know.... diff ppl diff tastes.....
the speakers, music interface and all is just grrrrrrrrrrrrr8! i love it more than my xperia and i phone and thats saying something....

good review. can't wait for the n97 to come out and see a review on that.. not too sure if i want to get it now after seeing this.

dis phone is acctuly relli good trust me

Noahh i think ur crazy haha i love the full qwerty. I think if you gave it more time and had an open mind it would grow on you. thank you though