Kyle Frost expert
News Editor and Reviewer Today's iPhone
Kyle is an avid tech fanatic, who got his start in technology by purchasing the original iPod touch, and decided to take up iOS development in 2009, a year after Apple opened the platform to third parties. Many like to portray him as an Apple fanboy, however he enjoys using all types of devices and thinks all deserve a fair shot. However Apple is his company of choice.
Follow TiP_Kyle
Kyle's current smartphone rankings
Why I made my choices
A new week, and new devices. As has been for a while now, the iPhone 5 still tops my list. I am an Apple person all around, using a MacBook Air as my travel computer and an iMac as my desktop choice. Due to this, the integration that iCloud brings with syncing everything from my Pages documents to my Safari tabs makes me go back to the iPhone anytime. The second and 3rd devices are both Android, however, with the Nexus 4 and the HTC One. The Nexus 4 offers a 'Google experience' of Android 4.2.2 Jelly Bean, which is by far the best version of Android I have ever used; but you'd expect that with it being the newest. The One is the 'iPhone of Android devices' when it comes to build quality. The build quality of the HTC One is absolutely brilliant. In 4th is a new device, the Lumia 928, which is Verizon's version of the Lumia 920. The device is a little lighter and thinner than the 920, however, and still packs that fantastic PureView camera. In 5th is Samsung's newest device, the Galaxy S 4. This device, despite feeling like a piece of flimsy plastic that my younger brother could snap in half, packs some great specs and software features, earning it the 5th spot on my list.
Kyle's ranking archives
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
The HTC One is now in 3rd, as I was able to get some more hands on time with the device and decided that it deserved to be above the Z10. Nothing against the Z10, but it doesn't come close to the beautifulness of the One's design. The metal unibody finish and front facing speakers are phenomenal. The Z10, however, still earns itself a nice 4th place, as the feel in hand of the device is still nice. However, because of the developer-lacking BB10 operating system, it couldn't hold 3rd forever. Last off is the HTC 8X. If I had to permanently switch to Windows Phone 8 (hope that never happens though), than I would choose the 8X as my device. It is a truly beautiful WP8 device, and compliments the OS that it runs very well. When you see and hold the phone, it just feels like it should run WP8, and, well, it does.
Why I made my choices...
The HTC One is now in 3rd, as I was able to get some more hands on time with the device and decided that it deserved to be above the Z10. Nothing against the Z10, but it doesn't come close to the beautifulness of the One's design. The metal unibody finish and front facing speakers are phenomenal. The Z10, however, still earns itself a nice 4th place, as the feel in hand of the device is still nice. However, because of the developer-lacking BB10 operating system, it couldn't hold 3rd forever. Last off is the HTC 8X. If I had to permanently switch to Windows Phone 8 (hope that never happens though), than I would choose the 8X as my device. It is a truly beautiful WP8 device, and compliments the OS that it runs very well. When you see and hold the phone, it just feels like it should run WP8, and, well, it does.
Why I made my choices...
The BlackBerry Z10 comes in third as, while it is a great 'remake' of BlackBerry's previous failures, it still isn't up to par with the major players. The developer support for BB10, the Z10's operating system, is very low, however on the rise. With better developer support, and updates that fix or add features not yet found in the infant OS, BlackBerry could finally be on the rise again. In 4th and 5th are two HTC devices. The HTC One in 4th has to be one of the best built devices Android has ever seen. The best way to put it is that if you want iPhone build quality and Android ecosystem, the One is for you. However, HTC Sense 5 is worse in some ways than previous versions, however it is also better in others. Lastly the 8X comes in at 5th with Windows Phone 8 in tow. The 8X is my view of a perfect WP8 device, however WP8 also holds it back. With the same problems as BB10, WP8 needs to mature and gain some more developer support.
Why I made my choices...
The new comer of the list comes in at number 4, the HTC One. This device takes the spot of the DROID DNA. Why? Simple - design. The One has a beautiful build, and really sets a new benchmark for hardware in Android. The One has a great looking design, and I hope (and wish) other Android OEMs would follow in HTC's footsteps. Unfortunately, Samsung has stuck with plastic, which just feels cheap. If Samsung would move to metal or glass, I would be much more sympathetic with them (notice I refuse to rank the Galaxy S III, simply because the design is horrid). I most likely will not like the Galaxy S 4 because of the lack of quality build materials.
Lastly, the same as before, the HTC 8X is in 5th. HTC has done a great job with building a fantastic Windows Phone 8 device in the 8X. I have yet to really use WP8 to its potential, but often find myself contemplating it. If I ever decided to take the plunge, it'd be on this device.
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
My list starts off with the 'big 3' in mobile operating systems. The iPhone 5 with iOS 6.1, the Nexus 4 with Android 4.2, and the BlackBerry Z10 running BB10. Each phone is the best at running its respective OS. Next comes two HTC devices which continue to catch my eye. The DROID DNA with its unbelievable specs, and the 8X with Windows Phone 8. The DNA is a great device with a beautiful display. The 8X is, in my opinion, the best Windows Phone 8 device.
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
Sitting at 4th and 5th are my former 3rd and 4th place holders - the two HTC devices. The DROID DNA earns its spot because of its long spec list, beginning with its 5-inch 1080p HD display. This device sets a new bar for great displays. The 8X is, in my opinion, the best Windows Phone 8 device available. It feels great in hand and has a great feel when using the phone. Windows Phone 8 will never make it as a leading platform, but it is a great 3rd choice, now competing though with BlackBerry.
Why I made my choices...
Why I made my choices...
The 3rd place DROID DNA holds its spot because of the awesome specs that it holds, including that 1080p display that is the first thing you see. The 8X is another HTC device, except it runs Windows Phone 8. However, its great feel in hand is one reason I love the device. Lastly, the Note II still holds its oversized spot at number 5. That huge screen has its definite upsides, and the great battery life is a major reason it is in my top 5 devices.
Why I made my choices...
Another Android device on the list, the DROID DNA sits at 3rd, with its incredible set of specs that is all topped off by a 1080p 5-inch display. The display on this device is absolutely remarkable, and unmatched. 4th and 5th remain the 8X and Note II, respectively. The 8X is HTC's Windows Phone 8 device, that really is a great looking phone. It comes in a few different color options, and runs on LTE. I love this device, and have considered making it my daily driver to get a better feel for Windows Phone 8. The Note II holds its own at number 5 with that huge display that so many seem to love. That part isn't my favorite, but the rest of the device features (most notably, battery life) is what earns it a spot in my rankings.
Why I made my choices...
The next 3 remained the same as well. The DROID DNA sits at 3rd with its insane spec sheet, including a 5' 1080p display which is the best display around. Another HTC device sits at 4th in the 8X. The 8X has tempted me to grab one, as it is a beautiful device and WP8 is starting to finally mature in the applications market. At 5th, the Note II still rests comfortably, with that 5.5' display and fantastic battery life, this device is great if you can wrap your minds (and hands) around having a 5.5' phone.
Why I made my choices...
The lower 3 all stayed the same as well, with the DROID DNA, the 8X, and the Note II. All phones are great, and have their own pros compared to others. The DNA has its gorgeous display which really is unmatched alongside some awesome specs. The 8X is my favorite of the Windows Phone devices, mostly because of its design which feels great in hand. The Note II, of course, as that giant screen that so many seem to love. It isn't my favorite, but the rest of the features make it a worth while device.
Why I made my choices...
The DROID DNA sits at 3rd because, for one, I love HTC devices, even if Sense has become overbearing, and HTC has spec'ed this phone out. It has the best screen, and some of the best internals. Another HTC device sits comfortably at number 4, the 8X. This Windows Phone 8 sporting device has a great design, and I love how it feels in hand. Microsoft is doing a great job at offering an alternative to iOS and Android, it just lacks in the app department.
Finally, the semi-newcomer. This device has made appearances before, and, pushing my distaste for Samsung aside, the Note II is back at number 5. The big screen really has its niche in the market. Not only that but the phone runs some great specs too. Samsung is a force to be reckoned with, and that probably is what has Apple going after them.
Why I made my choices...
The newest pure Google phone, the Nexus 4, still sits at second place. I really like the Nexus 4, as it shows how far Android has come in the past few years, and the potential that Android can have on a beautiful looking device.
Third, fourth, and fifth all remain the same with the DNA, Lumia 920, and 8X, respectively. The DNA has killer features and the best display I've seen, but Sense really holds it back. Windows Phone 8 on the others is better than Windows Phone 7, however it still doesn't really compete with Android and iOS in my opinion. It is a great 3rd place choice though.
Why I made my choices...
The two Android beasts sit at second and third with the Nexus 4 and DROID DNA. The Nexus 4 beats out the monster spec packing DROID DNA because of a reason that has been persistent in my ratings, stock Android. The only Android devices I like at this point are stock ones. I even own a Nexus 7 which I enjoy very much. The DROID DNA, however, does easily wins in the screen department with its 5' 1080p screen.
The Windows Phone 8 duo sits at numbers 4 and 5. The Lumia 920 coming just behind the 8X this week however because I had some more time with the camera, and wow is it amazing. If you could have the camera of the 920, the screen of the DNA, and stock Android, you'd be looking at the phone to knock off the iPhone 5. But that phone, doesn't yet exist.
Why I made my choices...
The Nexus 4 offers the best Android experience by far. With stock Android 4.2.1 Jelly Bean and a much improved design when compared to its plastic, Samsung made predecessor. Android has come a long way, and this phone shows that off.
The DROID DNA surpassed the Lumia 920 and the 8X for one major reason: the 1080p 5' display. I had some more time to use it and concluded that the screen really is one of the best I've seen. It is crystal clear, and I thought it was deserving of a higher ranking. Sense 4 is still too much, and if it was toned down (or better yet, just left as stock Android) then it would be a much cleaner experience.
The Windows Phone 8 devices sit at #4 and #5 with the 8X and Lumia 920. Both are fantastically built, and each has its respective pros and cons. I personally prefer the 8X simply because I've always been more fond of HTC devices, however it is a close race, as the Lumia 920 has a fantastic camera. Either of these is a great choice if you want to go the WP8 route.
Why I made my choices...
Google's newest device in the Nexus line of phones, the Nexus 4, sits comfortably at 2nd on my list. The stock experience offered on this device makes it the best Android phone around, beating out devices with monstrous specifications like the DROID DNA (which came in at #5). Android 4.2 has come a long way in terms of user experience, and it is really becoming a great looking operating system.
Windows Phone 8 takes #3 and #4 in the form of the HTC 8X and the Nokia Lumia 920. Windows Phone 8, while still not quite on par in my opinion with iOS and Android, is definitely a step or two up from WP7. The 8X and Lumia 920 are great examples of that. The design is great, and both have their plusses.
Rounding off the top 5 is the DROID DNA. This 'superphone' from HTC is crazy in the specs department. 1080p screen, quad-core 1.5GHz processor, 8MP camera, 5' display, 4G LTE, and more. The only downside is HTC Sense. It is just over the top now, and this device would really benefit with stock Android.
Why I made my choices...
The Nexus 4 holds its own at number 2, with its great looking design much improving over its predecessor, the Galaxy Nexus. Google also has come a long ways with Android 4.2, and it really is becoming a beautiful operating system.
The 8X and Lumia 920 still sit at 3 and 4, respectively. Each running Microsoft's newest mobile offering, Windows Phone 8, they both are great devices and feel great in hand. The feel of WP8 is more matured than WP7, but still not on par with Android and iOS in my opinion.
The newcomer easing its way up the rankings this week is the super-specced DROID DNA. This phone from HTC has specs not quite seen in one device before. A quad-core 1.5GHz processor with a 1080p display, Android 4.1 Jelly Bean, and an 8MP camera. It is a great device. However, HTC Sense is too much for me. Put stock Android 4.2 Jelly Bean on this, and it knocks off the Nexus 4 at number 2.
Why I made my choices...
The number one hasn't changed as the iPhone just doesn't have competition for this spot in my eyes, though the Nexus 4 is close. The iPhone offers the best software experience with its ecosystem that intertwines with Apple's desktop OS X software. It is indeed the best iPhone yet.
Number 3 and 4 are the same as last week with the 8X and Lumia 920. Both running Windows Phone 8, they each have their pros and cons. The Lumia is known for having a spectacular low-light camera, but I have always loved HTC build quality. That's the reason the 8X has a slight advantage to me.
5th place is the previous 2nd place phone, the RAZR MAXX HD. I always said that what it needed was stock Android. Well, now that the new Nexus is here, we have that stock experience, and it will beat out an OEM skinned phone anytime.
Why I made my choices...
The best consumer smartphone, for anyone out there, still sits at the #1 spot, the iPhone 5. It is just the best device for any consumer with its great software and ecosystem. Still hanging in 2nd is the DROID RAZR MAXX HD. The combination of great battery life, near stock Android 4.0 (and hopefully soon-to-be 4.1 or 4.2), and a great display earns it the same spot as weeks before.
The two newcomers slide in at #3 and #4. The HTC 8X barely edging out the Nokia Lumia 920 for a bias reason, I love HTC devices. The 8X is coming soon to VZW (my carrier of choice) and is out on AT&T. The Lumia 920 is still a great device, and the camera is phenomenal. Both run Windows Phone 8, Microsoft's most recent mobile OS. They are virtually a tie.
The Galaxy Note II still hangs on at #5 because it is a great device for many. If you love big screens, TouchWiz, and great battery life, the Note II would be a fine choice. I'm not the biggest fan of the large screens, but they definitely have a market.
- Apple iPhone 5
- Motorola DROID RAZR MAXX HD
- Samsung Galaxy Nexus (global)
- Samsung Galaxy Note II
- Apple iPhone 4S
Why I made my choices...
The Motorola DROID RAZR MAXX HD is still in 2nd. I love the battery life it provides, with a near stock Android experience. I still say, if this was stock Android 4.1 (or soon to be 4.2) it would be challenging the iPhone 5 as my top. Stock Android 4.1 is the reason my 3rd remains the Galaxy Nexus. The Nexus 4 will likely replace this though when it comes out.
4th is where the change is. While I still love the build of the One X, the Note II has grown on me. The software isn't the best looking (I don't like TouchWiz), but the experience of the new S Pen is very unique. If you like the larger screen, the Note II is great.
5th remains the iPhone 4S. At $99, it's a steal. It has a great 8MP camera, the A5 processor, iOS 6, Siri, and the gorgeous Retina display. You can't go wrong with this device.
Why I made my choices...
The Galaxy Nexus I expected to replace next week, but it seems the Google event has been cancelled due to a hurricane. That stays on my list because of the same reason as last week, stock Android 4.1 Jelly Bean. I have yet to find an Android device built better than the HTC One X. It is the only device in the same category as Apple's build quality. For that, it earns 4th again.
I was debating between the iPhone 4S and the Galaxy Note II for 5th. I stuck with the 4S because it is just a fantastic device for its price range. You are getting more than a bang for your buck. The Note II, while great, just doesn't fit every consumer.
















