Two heavyweights on T-Mobile. One winner. Let the dogfight begin! Aaron places the Samsung Galaxy S 4G and T-Mobile myTouch 4G into the ring. The Galaxy S 4G is a revision to the Vibrant and offers a 1 GHz Hummingbird processor, 4-inch Super AMOLED display, 5-megapixel camera, front-facing camera, larger battery, and Android 2.2 with Samsung's TouchWiz user interface. The T-Mobile myTouch 4G is powered by a 1 GHz next-generation Snapdragon processor and has a 3.8-inch display, 5-megapixel camera, front-facing camera, and Android 2.2 with HTC's Sense UI.

As always, both devices are contenders in T-Mobile's high-end lineup, but only one can take home the gold. Which one will it be? Part 1 of 2.

Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Products mentioned in this Article

eBay prices for the HTC myTouch 4G Black

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

98 Reactions to this post

"Which should it be, Facebook fans - Galaxy S 4G, or myTouch 4G?"

Please limit your reaction to 140 characters or use comments for a longer reply :)
Thanks for your participation! :)

Daniel Price
Daniel Price Get the MyTouch 4G. Samsung sucks.
Johny Jle
Johny Jle my touch 4g
Ryan Bassil Yousif
Ryan Bassil Yousif Galaxy S
Sam Rick
Sam Rick Neither.
Joshua Recon
Joshua Recon MYTOUCH4G!It is awesome my sister have it :)
Justin Medina
Justin Medina MT4G
Mason Hartley
Mason Hartley Mytouch hd blows any phone away only phone that can compare is the ....... Nothing....... HTC over did themselfs on this one
Mason Hartley
Mason Hartley Oh ya for got to put mytouch FTW
Mason Hartley
Mason Hartley Since the galaxy s 4g in simple terms is not better then the mytouch 4g and good luck to anyone who has a galaxy s 4g because most likely you'll be stuck on 2.2 forever
Scott-Christina Sherrell
Scott-Christina Sherrell My touch 4g , hands down
Robert Simmons
Robert Simmons Mytouch all the way
Parin Daulat
Parin Daulat Seems mytouch4G is fans fav
Sabreea Parnell
Sabreea Parnell Mytouch 4g all day
Kevin Xiong
Kevin Xiong I love my Mytouch 4g. Its almost the best!!!
Kalil S. Stoudmire
Kalil S. Stoudmire Mytouch 4g
John Cantu
John Cantu MYTOUCH 4G!!!!
Mikey Smith
Mikey Smith Don't you love how the question is about 2 phones and people say phones that are not even part of the topic... anyhow mt4g blows any phone out of the water at this point, especially when rooted and running stock android 2.3.3.
Steve Trujillo
Steve Trujillo My touch 4g rocks...
Jack Kramer
Jack Kramer Mytouch with cyanogen 7. Stock senseish crap on it sucks but the hardware is great. I miss the hardware flash on phones without it, like the galaxy s 4g.
Erick Contreras
Erick Contreras Definitely the galaxy s 4g, the Powervr sgx(I can't remember what number) is way more powerful than the adreno 205 found in the mytouch 4g
Emmanuel Castro
Emmanuel Castro Had the mytouch, no thanks GS4g.
Ashley Tho
Ashley Tho Is there any diffrence between samsung galaxy s and samsung galaxy s vibrant 4G?
Mike Mota
Mike Mota Can you guys not read? Its asking between the galaxy 4g and MT4G. Nobody cares what phone you have or want. I'll say the galaxy 4g MT4G isn't my thing.
Jeremy Steik
Jeremy Steik Iphone was not in question and is not even a 4g phone. My touch 4g is a better user experience!
Fabian Narez
Fabian Narez HTC inspire
Marcus NinersEmpire
Marcus NinersEmpire IPhone sucks Android all day everyday
Doug Fischer
Doug Fischer I still love my droid
David Morgan
David Morgan Mytouch 4g, better build quality (DOESN'T FEEL CHEAP)battery life is typical. Not a fan of touchwiz overlay. But I am envious of the super amoled screen :)
Noel Lv
Noel Lv I would get the galaxy bcus of the bigger battery .but I love the mytouch ..although I think its stupid they didn't put flash on the galaxy ..but theres no need cus I have the best ..evo 4g baby !
Miguel Marquez
Miguel Marquez Samsung lags on updates. Mytouch family hasn't let us down. Like the promised 2.0 update for the behold 2. Never buying a samsung never again.
Alex Ochoa
Alex Ochoa HTC G2 4g
Ryan Edward Johnson
Ryan Edward Johnson I'll keep my myTouch 4G
Michael Mahoney
Michael Mahoney I'm really enjoying my Galaxy S4G... if I crave an update I'll just root it and put CM7 on it...
Chuck Xu
Chuck Xu Htc pryamid!
Jabin George
Jabin George Samsung need to step up the game. The quad standard test is an insult compaired to the other devices.
Juan Ramirez
Juan Ramirez i seriously need people to decide for me. ive been dying over both of these
Dustin Taylor
Dustin Taylor Mytouch
Brett James Burgoyne
Brett James Burgoyne Sense UI is a million times better than touchwiz. The only things the galaxy s 4g has over the mytouch 4g are the screen and it has hspa+ 21mbps.
Alex Shubert
Alex Shubert Mytouch 4g
Michael Miller
Michael Miller DROID BIONIC
Anonymous My touch. I despise samsung and their antics towards the consumers. You can argue if they had to update on one carrier. But they have the same phone on all 4 carriers and no update. Im ok, htc over samsung.
Donnell Malpress
Donnell Malpress HTC hd7
Mike R Greco
Mike R Greco BAHAHAHHAHAHA anyone who thinks mytouch4g is good you should go buy a wp7
Thuderbolt Espino
Thuderbolt Espino MyTouch 4g
Harrison Hughes
Harrison Hughes Galaxy s but froyo is much better than gingerbread
Francisco E. Moscoso
Francisco E. Moscoso MyTouch 4g
Amanda Gomez
Amanda Gomez My touch 4g :D
Jean-David Felix
Jean-David Felix Galaxy
Mike Nguyen
Mike Nguyen Galaxy S 4G of course
Mike Nguyen
Mike Nguyen Atrix 4g
Austin Jae
Austin Jae MyTouch. You can't trust Samsung to ever update their phones or fix anything that might end up being wrong.
Kevin Lee
Kevin Lee Droid x
Jack Zhang
Jack Zhang Galaxy
Brad Nielsen
Brad Nielsen htc evo 4g
Jeffrey Jazzy Jeff Jones
Jeffrey Jazzy Jeff Jones Mytouch 4g is the shit.
French Twist
French Twist Hmmm... I don't know Aaron, that's a tough one. Why don't you send them both over and I'll tell ya! ;)
Nancy Dela Cruz
Nancy Dela Cruz i have the samsung vibrant.....BUT the MY4 has front facing camera AND FLASH.....i say mytouch 4...i think im gonna get it now
Kandi KillinemwitKindness Williams
Kandi KillinemwitKindness Williams MyTouch 4G
Jamille Browne
Jamille Browne @Jerry there are by far more roms on the galaxy s than mt4g and HTC has nothing on Samsung but a bunch of clueless fanboys
Evan Cheney
Evan Cheney they both suck'
Alex Weiler
Alex Weiler Galaxy s 4g
Juan Antonio Villegas
Juan Antonio Villegas mytouch 4g is way ahead better
John Steies
John Steies I really enjoy my galaxy s 4 g
Steve Christopher
Steve Christopher Just got the HTC inspire on AT&T. I'm loving it, the phone no doubt rocks. Quick and responsive.
Nate Peters
Nate Peters I'll never buy Samsung again. Enough said.
Kostas Pagratis
Kostas Pagratis Galaxy!!
Jerry Adney
Jerry Adney HTC > Samsung as a rule. Haven't played with either of these but considering how many ROMs are out for HTC phones compared to Sammy I tend to go with them overall.
Yorgule Miklos
Yorgule Miklos i'll go with myTouch 4G... I'LL NEVER BUY A SAMSUNG ANYMORE
Kris K. Blomgren
Kris K. Blomgren Neither...T-Mobile sucks. I just left them.
Dallas Johnson
Dallas Johnson I say whatever phone floats your boat...lol
Daniel Hernandez
Daniel Hernandez i know this doesnt have anything to do with it but is the pantech jest a good second phone, i have the samsung intensity and its gay :p
Jason Miller
Jason Miller galaxy the mytouch hinge mechanism is plain old stupid and nto to rigid
Tim Gruber
Tim Gruber mytouch for sure
Vincent Del Pizzo
Vincent Del Pizzo Galaxy s
James Muigai Nyoike
James Muigai Nyoike Mytouch 4g
Hamid Reza Mossavi
Hamid Reza Mossavi My Frikin touch...duhhhh...
Jesus Lugo
Jesus Lugo Galaxy S 4G!
Jurron Jackson
Jurron Jackson MyTouch 4G!!!
Jay InigoMontoya Lopez
Jay InigoMontoya Lopez Galaxy s minus twlauncher and tweaked a little..... in the words of charlie.. "WINNER"
Justin Wade
Justin Wade Galaxy!!!
Domi Absalom Walton-Jackson
Domi Absalom Walton-Jackson Mytouch 4g more ram than galaxy 4g...
Vinny Cicatello
Vinny Cicatello Mt4g
Jerry Kallinikos
Jerry Kallinikos mytouch 4g, great phone so far
David Montes
David Montes I use an iPhone and an Atrix 4g, I'd still go with the Galaxy 4G cuz my first smart phone was my reliable samsung captivate :)
Debra Diriwachter
Debra Diriwachter Galaxy s 4g
Lindsey R. Shiggs
Lindsey R. Shiggs MyGalaxy 4S Dammit! I want both!
Philip Perry
Philip Perry Galaxy S 4G!
Saaqib Malek
Saaqib Malek Both are the best I used both.of these phones now im using sidekick 4g
Kurt Rusheen Tacastacas
Kurt Rusheen Tacastacas iPhone 4G!
Roderico Willis
Roderico Willis Evo 4G
Stephen Hicks
Stephen Hicks iPhone 4
Eric Taylor
Eric Taylor The Galaxy s 4g n when the free smartphone come back up i hear was in spring?
David Arellano
David Arellano Galaxy in hardware. If it goes anything like the other Galaxy S variants in terms of software updates, then not even the hardware will compensate for the lack in OS performance.
Adam Chase
Adam Chase Galaxy s
Victor Rios
Victor Rios MT4G
Saaqib Malek
Saaqib Malek Iphone is gayy
Taylor Allen
Taylor Allen myTouch 4g!!!!!!!!!!!! :)
Dave Keller
Dave Keller I'd choose the galaxy s, but its obvious you're going to choose the mytouch.

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices