PhoneDog Media Exclusive
Download iM5, now available in the App Store and Google Play. iM5 is a PhoneDog Media backed Social Platform to inspire real-life action through the crowdsourcing of ideas. See the video

"Which phone should I get?" Given my line of work, I get this question regularly from friends, family, and colleagues. Choosing a carrier is tough enough, but the sheer number of phones available (with more arriving each week) complicates a buying decision even more.

With school starting in a few weeks, it's time to take a look at some of the devices on the market. We've divided the list into two categories - smartphones and featurephones - depending on the age of your loved one(s). In most cases, the phones you see below aren't the newest devices on the block, but they're all reasonably priced, well-equipped, and recommended for the hustle and bustle that accompanies back to school time. For additional information, including in-depth specifications, videos, and reviews, be sure to click on the "Product Hub" link.


Apple iPhone 4G (AT&T)

Apple iPhone 4

  • Buy this if: You're a media buff who wants a first class music and web experience.
  • Don't buy this if: You want widgets or a subtle notification system.
  • Buyer Beware: Don't hold the phone in the much ballyhooed lower left hand corner.
  • Pleasant Surprise: The "Retina Display" is absolutely gorgeous, and battery life has been surprisingly good.
  • Dark Secret: Download fring and video chat with non-iPhone users.
  • Alternatives: HTC Droid Incredible (Verizon), Samsung Captivate (AT&T), Samsung Vibrant (T-Mobile).

iPhone 4G Review Available at RadioShack

T-Mobile myTouch 3G Slide

HTC myTouch 3G Slide

  • Buy this if: You like Android and want a physical QWERTY keyboard.
  • Don't buy this if: You don't like a heavily customized user interface over Android.
  • Buyer Beware: HTC has placed a custom interface on the myTouch 3G Slide, so Android updates could take longer to arrive.
  • Pleasant Surprise: Great physical keyboard.
  • Dark Secret: Hinge can get a bit wobbly after extended use.
  • Alternatives: LG Ally (Verizon), Samsung Intercept (Sprint)

myTouch 3G Review Available at RadioShack

Palm Pre Plus

Palm Pre Plus

  • Buy this if: You want a nice mid-range smartphone with a smart OS.
  • Don't buy this if: You like a ton of apps, since Palm's App Catalog is pretty bare in comparison to the competition.
  • Buyer Beware: The Pre series is well over a year old, so a revised model could arrive any day now.
  • Pleasant Surprise: Verizon has been offering Mobile Hotspot for free, a $20 value.
  • Dark Secret: Battery life isn't the best.
  • Alternatives: HTC DROID Incredible (Verizon), HTC Aria (AT&T).

Palm Pre Plus » Available at RadioShack

HTC Aria (AT&T)

HTC Aria

  • Buy this if: You want a nice mid-range device in a small package.
  • Don't buy this if: You have big hands and like to type long messages.
  • Buyer Beware: You can't sideload unofficial apps on AT&T's Android devices, so the device isn't for the enthusiast.
  • Pleasant Surprise: Well-equipped small device in a world of behemoths.
  • Dark Secret: With a smaller device comes a smaller battery, so you may need to carry a car charger.
  • Alternatives: HTC Hero (Sprint), LG Ally (Verizon).

HTC Aria Review Available at RadioShack

BlackBerry Bold 9650

BlackBerry Bold 9650

  • Buy this if: You want reliable push e-mail service, and have several friends with BlackBerry devices.
  • Don't buy this if: You enjoy music or web browsing; BlackBerry doesn't handle either particularly well.
  • Buyer Beware: BlackBerry has used a similar platform for years, so the operating system may seem outdated in comparison to others.
  • Pleasant Surprise: Trackpad and added memory make for a better experience, and as always, the physical keyboard is fantastic.
  • Dark Secret: The Bold takes several minutes to power on.
  • Alternatives: BlackBerry Bold 9700 (AT&T, T-Mobile), HTC myTouch 3G Slide (T-Mobile).

BlackBerry Bold 9650 Review Available at RadioShack

Samsung Vibrant

Samsung Vibrant

  • Buy this if: You want a feature-packed Android device with a beautiful "Super AMOLED" display.
  • Don't buy this if: You like the standard Android interface, because Samsung's TouchWiz is completely different.
  • Buyer Beware: The 5.0-megapixel camera doesn't have a flash.
  • Pleasant Surprise: Avatar is pre-loaded on the device (yep, the full movie).
  • Dark Secret: Suffers from the occasional lag.
  • Alternatives: Motorola DROID X (Verizon), HTC EVO 4G (Sprint), Samsung Captivate (AT&T).

Samsung Vibrant Review Available at RadioShack



Pantech Link

Pantech Link

  • Buy this if: You want a slick, clean messaging device.
  • Don't buy this if: You want a powerful camera, since Link only offers a 1.3-megapixel shooter.
  • Buyer Beware: Some have reported call quality issues.
  • Pleasant Surprise: The keyboard is spacious and incredibly easy to type on, and battery life is quite good.
  • Dark Secret: The HTML browser is frustrating to use at times.
  • Alternatives: Samsung Magnet (AT&T).

Pantech Link Review Available at RadioShack

Samsung Gravity 3

Samsung Gravity 3

  • Buy this if: You're on T-Mobile and want a good messaging device.
  • Don't buy this if: The "sliding QWERTY" form factor isn't your thing.
  • Buyer Beware: The Gravity 3 doesn't offer a dedicated headphone jack.
  • Pleasant Surprise: The keyboard is roomy and easy to use.
  • Dark Secret: The Gravity 3 suffers from some occasional call quality issues.
  • Alternatives: LG Cosmos (Verizon), Samsung Intensity (Verizon).

Samsung Gravity 3 Review Available at RadioShack

Samsung Reality

Samsung Reality

  • Buy this if: Your budget is for a featurephone but you want the ability to customize.
  • Don't buy this if: You dislike additional features; the Reality requires a $9.99 (or higher) data plan.
  • Buyer Beware: Camera quality isn't the best.
  • Pleasant Surprise: Samsung's TouchWiz user interface offers a nice level of customization.
  • Dark Secret: Despite being the successor to the Samsung Rogue, it skimps out on a few features like screen size and data speed.
  • Alternatives: Samsung Smiley (T-Mobile), LG enV3 (Verizon)

Samsung Reality Review Available at RadioShack

LG VU Plus

LG VU Plus

  • Buy this if: You're on a budget but want a nice, well-equipped featurephone.
  • Don't buy this if: You find capacitive touchscreen displays frustrating.
  • Buyer Beware: Keyboard is somewhat squished together.
  • Pleasant Surprise: With a capacitive touchscreen, 3.0-megapixel camera, and stereo Bluetooth, it offers quite a few features.
  • Dark Secret: Lack of a 3.5mm headphone jack could be frustrating for music fans.
  • Alternatives: Samsung Gravity T (T-Mobile), LG enV Touch (Verizon).

LG VU Plus Review Available at RadioShack



  • Buy this if: You're buying a featurephone and want a good music and web experience.
  • Don't buy this if: You dislike additional features; the EnV3 requires a $9.99 (or higher) data plan.
  • Buyer Beware: It's approaching old age, so the EnV 4 could be on the market soon.
  • Pleasant Surprise: One of the best QWERTY keyboards on a featurephone.
  • Dark Secret: After extended use, some users have reported issues with "OK" button.
  • Alternatives: Samsung Reality (Verizon).

LG EnV3 Review Available at RadioShack

Samsung Reclaim

Samsung Reclaim

  • Buy this if: You want a solid messaging device that's also eco-friendly.
  • Don't buy this if: You're looking for a professional color, since the Reclaim ships in blue and green.
  • Buyer Beware: Call quality was shaky at times.
  • Pleasant Surprise: 40 percent of Reclaim's casing is made from corn.
  • Dark Secret: 3G connectivity occasionally faded out during testing.
  • Alternatives: Samsung Restore (Sprint), LG Remarq (Sprint).

Samsung Reclaim Review Available at RadioShack

Don't forget to VOTE! Each week, PhoneDog Fans vote for their #1 smartphone in the Official Smartphone Rankings. Vote now and contribute to the industry's most relevant weekly ranking charts

Related posts

Comments & discussions  

Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos
Most popular Videos

Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions
Most popular Reactions

This weeks "People's Choice Rankings" best smartphones
People's Choice Rankings

See all hot devices